Sunday, June 24, 2012

No Explanations

sermon by Torin Eikler
I Samuel 15:34-16:13              I Samuel 17:57-18:16


There’s a lot that can’t be explained in this story of the beginning of David’s reign starting with the fact that David was chosen to begin with.  Saul had not been chosen by the people or even by Samuel after all.  He had been chosen by YHWH and anointed with oil and the Spirit to lead the people, … and he had been successful!  He had returned the Ark of the Covenant to its rightly place, driven off at least three invasions, and reestablished the original borders of the Promised Land.  Israel had once again become a force to be reckoned with, and other nations feared Saul’s army and the might of YHWH that stood behind it.  The only “mistake” that Saul had made was that he and the people failed to completely exterminate one of their oldest enemies.  For that “transgression” Saul was rejected as king, and YHWH set about choosing his … unexpected successor.

And David was a strange choice in and of himself.  He came from a questionable lineage that included prostitutes, foreigners, and failures – no wealth or standing, no great deeds or faithful works to recommend him.  On top of that, he was not just the youngest in his family.  (God does seem to make a habit of choosing little children to lead us, doesn’t she?) 

David was the eighth son, the one who was still too young to have taken up any responsibilities in the household proper – a child whose experience as a shepherd would hardly make him fit to rule a nation according to any human calculus imaginable.  Yet, it was David who was chosen.



Then, once David had been anointed (in a small private ceremony), … nothing happens … at least nothing spectacular.  “The Spirit of the Lord came mightily upon him” of course, but he did not rise up and take control of the nation as one might expect from the Lord’s anointed.  Instead, life went on as usual.  David went back to the sheep, and Saul went on leading the people to victory … at least until he came up Philistines and their champion, Goliath.

We didn’t hear that part of the story this morning, but you all probably remember how there was no one among Israel’s soldiers who was willing to go out and meet the challenge of Goliath.  David was still too young to be part of the fighting, though.  He was just bringing some food for his older brothers when he overheard the challenge, accepted it, somehow managed to defeat the Philistine champion with one sling pebble to the temple, and began the route of the Philistines.

On the way home, the people sang songs celebrating their king’s victory and the might of their army.  (The words of their song, by the way, were not exact.  Saul’s “thousands” and David’s “ten thousands” were more like Saul’s “many” and David’s “a lot”).  For some reason, that did not make Saul happy though there was enough admiration to go around.  Instead, he became suspicious of David, trying the very next day to kill him with a spear not once but twice.  Trying … and failing though he was an accomplished warrior and there was no place in the room for David to hide.


There are other … “questionable” things recorded in this part of the story as well, but remember that the books of Samuel are considered to be part of the historical books.  They hold the story of Israel’s past as interpreted by scribes and theologians of the time.  For generations, they were thought of as an accurate record of events, and there are still people who argue that everything happened in exactly this way.  The way we tend to think of things in our culture, though, this is at best magical realism if not outright fantasy….  It makes a great story, but it couldn’t have been true.  And yet, we all know that stories are often places where truths of great power are found.


Walter Brueggemann has suggested that because our own lives have the quality of narrated story, our attentiveness to narratives such as [these chapters] can have transforming effect.  The key lies in imaginatively attending to our stories alongside the biblical story. …  The imaginative juxtaposition of biblical story with personal story creates new possibilities both for understanding the claims of faith and for living transformed lives in the light of those claims.[1]
 
It takes no great imagination, while considering Saul or David, to find our life peopled with Jonathan … and singing women and ruthless spears and applauding crowds.  We draw very close to the narrative and we participate.  When we do draw close, criticism is overcome and the text narrates for us another world, a world in which love is possible and hatred goes crazy, in which success is rampant and the king fails, in which Yahweh is present in transformative ways.  David’s world is rich with people.  In our retelling of David’s story and David’s world, “our story” is repeopled….  When these stories are absent from our experience, everything is likely to be “explained.”  But then noticing is not possible: thrones are never risked, songs are never sung, [slings are never spun], … names are never precious.  When everything is “explained” life is denied and no new life is imaginable.[2]

What that means in a nutshell is that a world with wonder is a world without imagination, and without imagination, we cannot envision anything different than we have.  If everything can be explained than we live in a world of simple cause and effect.  The better you understand the world, the better you can plan for the future because always know what will happen next.  That may seem like a good thing at first, but without room for the unexpected, there can be no hope for change because life becomes like a machine that just keeps working the same way day in and day out.


In 2003, the movie “Big Fish” came out in theaters.  It was a vivid movie filled with inexplicable events, magic, and wonder.  The story revolved around a dying man and his son, (both named Ed), who was trying to learn more about his father by piecing together the stories he gathered over the years.  Ed Jr. managed to recreate a version of his father's elusive life that is, actually, a series of legends and myths loosely based on the few facts he actually knows and his father’s fanciful retellings.

Of course, everyone – the father, the son, and the audience all knew that the tall tales of witches, giants, and dwarves were fantasy, but as the son listened again to the stories – lived alongside his father as he relived his own life in story – Ed Jr. finally began to understand some of the deeper truths about his father’s greatness as well as his weaknesses.  Then, as his father’s life came to an end and he met some of the people who inspired the stories, he came to understand something else as well.  His father was neither a pathological liar nor ashamed of his past.  He had just been using his imagination to open new possibilities for the future by reinterpreting and embellishing the past.
 

I think that may be what’s going on in these stories of David rise to the throne.  Some scholars believe that the strange and miraculous stories we find here can be explained as an attempt to prove that David was not a deserter or a usurper, and that may be part of the truth.  But I think that this is history – history re-envisioned … history retold as story not just because it was an embarrassing episode or to make it more interesting, but history embellished and elaborated in order to bring out deeper truth and shape hope for a different future.

Both Saul and David had their strengths and their weaknesses (and you may hear more about David’s failings next week), and the stories celebrate the good points as well as highlighting the bad.  But, the big difference between David and Saul – the deeper truth that the authors are trying to show – is that David had an abiding faith in the power and wisdom of YHWH.  Where Saul’s successes led him to believe in his own wisdom and the power of his armies, David relied on the strength and protection of God.  David trusted that YHWH would be the decisive force in his world and that whatever happened – triumph or defeat – was in God’s hands.


Carrie and I have recently been watching “Glee.”  We’re only in the middle of the second season.  So, you may be a good deal farther along in the storyline of these High School students with exceptional voices.  But through the “magic” of Netflix, we can follow the story without all the interruptions … and without having to wait for weeks at a time until the next installment comes along….  Ah… technology.

In the latest episode, we found out that one of the girls still believed in Santa Claus (quite an accomplishment for a teen-ager).  And the Glee Club goes to great lengths to insure that she holds on to that belief because they all remember the sense of childish, magical wonder they used to have at Christmas, and they want to protect her faith, protect and preserve it. And, somehow they manage to do it.  They manage to pull off a Christmas “miracle.”


Brittany’s faith was in a magical Santa Claus.  Both Ed and Ed Jr. put their faith in the power of myth.  But David believed in something more … real – YHWH.  YHWH, the God of Abraham, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, and Joshua … the God of the Hebrew people … the living God who had loved, cherished, and protected the Israelites throughout a history of slavery, wandering, and invasion was the Spirit that had empowered him … chosen him to lead and to serve.


Who or What do you believe in?  Do you believe in the God of David, the Abba of Jesus?  Are you ready to follow a little child without explanation and against conventional wisdom?  Are you willing to step into the story that has been and is still being written, to give yourself fully to trusting that child to lead you into new life?

I hope so.  I hope we all find that faith within us … because only that kind of inexplicable trust can give us the courage to stand up to the evil and intimidation that the faces us across the “battlefields” of our world.  That kind of belief and the sense of wonder it gives can change the world, and in God’s story the future is filled with the promise of hope and salvation for our world … for us … for all of God’s children.



[1] Bruce C. Birch, “The First and Second Books of Samuel” in The New Interpreter’s Bible: A Commentary in Twelve Volumes, Leander E. Keck, editor (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1998) 1123.
[2] Walter Brueggemann, Power, Providence, and Personality (Louisville: Westminster/John Knox, 1990) 47-48.

No comments: