sermon by Carrie Eikler
Jeremiah 1:4-10
It has been a little over a month since I have seen most of you. What with denominational gatherings and meetings, vacation, and the death of two of our grandparents, we have been flying, literally around as far as St. Louis and Minneapolis, driving to the Outer Banks of North Carolina, and taking a first bus ride to Suncrest Primary for all day pre-school.
As much as I want to say it, I’m convinced it’s folly to say “when things settle down…” Things never really settle down, do they? There are periods of calm in the storm of life, but we always know there’s more on the horizon. And unfortunately, if you are anything like me, those periods of calm are treated somehow, if not subconsciously, simply as times to recuperate and prepare for the next storm to hit: secretly plotting our defenses, worrying about what could in fact come our way: Who will die next? What if this job isn’t here in a year? What if I am simply too burned out to continue with what I’ve been called to do?
Sometimes, it seems like the busy times are better than what we might call the “calm” times. What really destroys us is not dealing with the crises of life, but worrying about the possibility of them, like watching for the hurricane making its way up the coast. Will it really reach you where you are?
And let’s remember there are those among us who constantly live in turmoil: constant fear of lack of income or resources; fear of persecution for what they believe or who they love; chronic health conditions, and a lifetime of warfare. Where do they find calm in the midst of storms?
And yet, out of crisis comes calling. Doesn’t it always seem to work like that? Prophets never seem to be called during a down time. Living in exile, social calamity, anarchy…these are the sure grains of yeast for the rising up of a prophet! It seems like people never call on us, or need us, or want something from us when we have been properly rested and rejuvenated—it never seems to come when we have everything in order and now ready to proceed with an orderly amount of call.
Jeremiah exhibits our resistance to call in the time of calamity. Kingdoms were falling…and who does God pluck out of the rabble? A youth. We don’t know exactly how old Jeremiah is, but he calls himself a boy. I can’t do it! I’m too young, the problems too big. But before he can get more persuasive arguments out, God wipes them away with what I can only hear as a divine “tisk, tisk.” “Don’t say I am only a boy! Don’t say I’m not trained, I don’t have enough time, I get too flustered, I’m too scared.”
Like the seed that formed Jeremiah in his mother’s womb, the seed of God’s words were planted in him. And they are planted in us too, somewhere deep within us. But we can understand Jeremiah’s reluctance. It seems like God would want someone with more confidence, who can speak really loudly, not with reticence. Someone on fire for God. But I’m more reluctant when it comes to hearing a call. How about you?
“A reluctant prophet may be the only one worth calling” muses Martin B. Copenhaver. “A reluctant prophet may be the only one worth calling because he or she is likely to be the one who knows what is required to be a faithful prophet.” Most of us won’t be given authority over nations and kingdoms, like Jeremiah. But we are called, in our own ways, to pull down empires and plant new ones. The empires that control us, that guide our daily decision making, that keep us trapped in old patterns of acting and thinking and living.
And while it may seem simple and small, we know that the very least it takes courage to face ourselves. We may feel only like little girls and little boys as we face our own lives.
I love September because it brings the promise of cooler weather. Not that these first few days are any indication of that, but I know that by the end of the month, it will be cool. Leaves will begin to change, abundance will be redefined not by the massive amounts of tomatoes on the vines, but by the tomatoes in the jar keeping cool in my basement. Fall is a wonderful time to reacquaint ourselves.
This September I feel a different convergence of season in my life. We are currently in the midst of the Muslim holiday of Ramadan, when Muslims fast, pray, abstain, give extra, and work at reacquainting themselves with Allah, God. This month also brings the Jewish Holiday of Yom Kippur, the day of atonement, of asking forgiveness and setting straight one’s path. It’s kind of like the attention we might give at Lent as we explore the state of our souls.
For Christians this September doesn’t bring us any holiday calling us to repentance, confession, or forgiveness. Yet the call is there nevertheless. It comes as we remember September 11. It comes as we observe International Day of Peace on September 21. It comes as we embark on a study on human sexuality. It comes as we kiss the heads of our young children as we send them off to school. What comes? Life comes. Everyday life, whether calm or crisis, mundane or magical, every waking morning is the call of God-waking us with an urging to claim the call to everyday acts of love and compassion, even when we are reluctant, or ill-chosen, or don’t have the time.
Responding to the call to ministry was a reluctant one for me. I was rarely told that as a woman ministry was a viable option for me. I didn’t feel compelled to memorize scriptures in order to convince people I was well read in the Bible, which I wasn’t. I didn’t want to tell people how to live their lives, like I saw so many pastors doing.
What I did feel, however, was a call to accompany others through life, everyday life, the life that comes. That to me is ministry and that is why I love being part of an Anabaptist tradition because we believe that is all our call. We are all called to be priests, ministers, walking with others through crises and calm.
And the beauty about this call is for most of us, it doesn’t require us to relocate, or to change jobs, it doesn’t even require special equipment. It is a call to be a minister, maybe even a prophet, by giving daily blessings to others: through our words, our actions and decisions, our prayers. What if we attuned ourselves to listen, not just to those big calls in our lives—those infrequent, monumental changes that thrust us into something entirely new—but what if we gave equal weight to a simpler call: being in our everyday lives in a new way. Interacting with others in a new way. Living on earth, in a new way. Praying with God…in a new way.
If we gave weight to this call, we could take who we are, where we are as an answer to God’s calling—you are here, now walk with others, bearers of blessing.
And yet it takes courage and we can still be reluctant, I’m sure. It is uncomfortable to think about reacquainting our lives with God, rather than simply towards ourselves. And contrary to what we might think I’m not convinced that feeling uncomfortable is bad. I’m pretty sure that when we are uncomfortable in what God might be calling us to, it is only the beginning of God’s blessing. Like the labor pains of birthing the call that God plants within us, out of pain and resistance, comes new life: for ourselves, for God, and for others. And all are called to claim it.
Brian McLaren, theologian an author of the popular book A Generous Orthodoxy, likes to think of the church as a dojo. Any of you familiar with martial arts, or at least familiar with the original Karate Kid move (classic!), you know that a dojo is a place where people learn martial arts. It literally means “a place where one learns the way.” That’s what he thinks churches should be, but not only learning the way by listening to the pastor ramble on. Dojos are places where students learn by putting into practice. We practice here, what we learn here in order to be out there what we have formed in here.
So we are here to practice. We are now going to practice being bears of blessing, here in our “Jesus dojo.” Or maybe our, “Jeremiah dojo.” Many of the young children in our congregation are facing new experiences and new challenges with the new school year and we are going to practice our being bearers of blessing as we bestow them with our love and support. Some of you, grown children are also experience new experiences and challenges: starting school yourself, or a new job, or new family situations. Maybe you would like a spoken blessing as well. If that sounds like what you are experience, I’ll invite you to share that with us if you like, after we bless the children.
Sunday, September 5, 2010
Sunday, August 29, 2010
Courage to Speak
Melodrama by Torin Eikler
Esther
Narrator: After these things, when the anger of King Ahasuerus had abated, he remembered Vashti and what she had done and what had been decreed against her. Then the king passed and edict:
King Ahasuerus: “Let beautiful young virgins be sought out for the king. And let all the beautiful young virgins be brought to the royal harem and be put under the custody of Hegai, who is in charge of the women. And let the girl who pleases the king become queen instead of Vashti.
Narrator: Now, there was a Jew in the royal city whose name was Mordecai son of Jair son of Shimei son of Kish. Mordecai had raised Esther, for when her father and mother died, he adopted her as his own daughter. Esther was beautiful. So when the king’s edict was proclaimed, Esther was taken into the king’s palace and put in custody of Hegai, who had charge of the women.
Esther was admired by all who saw her, and when she was taken to King Ahasuerus, the king loved Esther more than all the others, and he set the royal crown on her head and made her queen. Then the king gave a great banquet, and granted a holiday to the provinces, and gave many gifts.
In those days, while Mordecai was sitting at the king’s gate, two of the king’s servants, Bigthan and Teresh, conspired to assassinate the king. But the Mordecai overheard their plan, and he told it to Queen Esther, and Esther told the king in the name of Mordecai. When the affair was investigated and found to be so, both the men were hanged on the gallows. It was recorded in the book of records in the presence of the king.
A little while later, King Ahasuerus promoted Haman son of Hammedatha to be his closest advisor and gave him the king’s ring. And all the king’s servants bowed down when Haman went by, for that was what the king had commanded. But Mordecai did not bow down. When Haman saw that Mordecai did not bow down to him, Haman was infuriated. So, having been told who Mordecai’s people were, Haman plotted to destroy all the Jews throughout the whole kingdom.
When Mordecai learned all that had been done, he tore his clothes and put on sackcloth and ashes, and went through the city, wailing with a loud and bitter cry. Then Esther sent a messenger to Mordecai to learn what was happening and why. The messenger did as Esther wished, and Mordecai told him …
Mordecai: Tell Esther that Haman is trying to destroy all the Jews and to wipe them off the face of the earth just because I refused to bow down to anyone other than the Lord our God. The queen must go before the king and beg for her people to be spared, for she, too, is a Jew.
Narrator: The messenger told all of this to Esther, and Esther sent him back with a reply.
Esther: Everyone knows that if any man or woman goes before the king without being called, they are to be put to death. Only if the king holds out the golden scepter to someone, may that person live. I myself have not been called by the king for thirty days.
Mordecai: Esther, Do not think that in the king’s palace you will escape any more than all the other Jews. For if you keep silence at such a time as this, deliverance will come from someone else, but you and your father’s family will perish. Who knows? Perhaps you have come to royal dignity for just such a time as this.
Esther: Go, gather all the Jews to be found in the city, and hold a fast on my behalf. Don’t eat or drink for three days and three nights. I and my maids will also fast as you do, and after that I will go to the king, though it is against the law. If I perish, I perish.”
Narrator: Esther then went away and did everything as Esther had ordered him.
On the third day Esther put on her royal robes and stood in the court opposite the king’s throne. As soon as the king saw Queen Esther standing in the court, he held out the golden scepter that was in his hand, and Esther went and touched the top of the scepter.
King Ahasuerus: What is it, Queen Esther? What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: If it pleases the king, let the king and Haman come today to a banquet that I have prepared for the king.
King Ahasuerus: Bring Haman quickly, so that we may do as Esther desires.
Narrator: So the king and Haman came to the banquet that Esther had prepared, and the king said to Esther….
King Ahasuerus: What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: This is my request … If I have won the king’s favor, and if it pleases the king to grant fulfill my request, let the king and Haman come tomorrow to the banquet that I will prepare for them, and then I will do as the king has said.
Narrator: Haman went out that day happy and in good spirits, but when he saw Modercai in the king’s gate, he got angry. He went home and sent for his friends and his wife.
Haman: (To the congregation) Look at me. How great a man am I?! I have been made the advisor of the king. I am filthy rich with thousands and thousands of talents in the bank. And I have many strong, smart, and obedient children to make me proud. Even Queen Esther let no one but myself come with the king to the banquet that she prepared. Tomorrow also I am invited by her, together with the king. Yet all this does me no good so long as I see the Jew Mordecai sitting at the king’s gate.
Narrator: Then his wife and all his friends said to him, “Let a gallows fifty cubits high be made, and in the morning tell the king to have Mordecai hanged on it; then go with the king to the banquet in good spirits.” This advice pleased Haman, and he had the gallows made.
On that night King Ahasuerus could not sleep, and he gave orders to bring the book of records. They were read to the king, and he remembered how Mordecai had told him about the two men who had conspired to assassinate him.
King Ahasuerus: What reward has been given to Mordecai to honor his service?
Narrator: The servant who attended him said …
Attendant: Nothing has been done for him.
King Ahasuerus: Who is in the court?
Attendant: Haman is there, standing in the court.
King Ahasuerus: Let him come in.
Narrator: So Haman came in.
King Ahasuerus: What shall be done for the man whom the king wishes to honor?
Haman: (to him/herself) Whom would the king wish to honor more than me?
(to the king) Let the king’s own royal robes be brought and one of the king’s horses with a royal crown on its head. Let the robes and the horse be handed over to one of the king’s most noble officials. Let him put the robes on the man whom the king wishes to honor, and lead that man on horseback through the open square of the city, proclaiming before him: ‘This is how the king shows his gratitude.’
King Ahasuerus: Quickly, take the robes and the horse, and do exactly as you have said to Mordecai.
Narrator: So Haman took the robes and the horse, dressed Mordecai, and led him on horseback through the open square of the city, proclaiming,
Haman: This is how the king shows his gratitude.
Narrator: Then Esther returned to the king’s gate, but Haman hurried to his house, with his head covered in shame and anger. When Haman told his wife and all his friends everything that had happened to him, they said to him, “If Mordecai is of the Jewish people, you will not prevail against him, but will surely fall before him.”
While they were still talking with him, the king’s eunuchs arrived and hurried Haman off to the banquet that Esther had prepared. So the king and Haman went in to feast with Queen Esther on the second day, and the king again said to Esther,
King Ahasuerus: What is it, Queen Esther? What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: If I have won your favor, O king, and if it pleases the king, let my life and the lives of my people be spared—that is my request. For we have been condemned to be wiped out. If we had been sold merely as slaves, I would have held my peace, but no one can make up for this with mere money.”
King Ahasuerus: Who has done this horrible thing?
Esther: There he is – it is Haman!
Narrator: The king rose from the feast in anger and went into the palace garden, but Haman stayed to beg his life from Queen Esther. When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet hall, Haman was grasping the feet of the queen, and the king said
King Ahasuerus: Will he even assault the queen in my own house?!
Narrator: Then one of the servants in attendance on the king, said,
Servant: Look, the very gallows that Haman has prepared for Mordecai, whose word saved the king, stands at Haman’s house, fifty cubits high.
King Ahasuerus: Take him there and dispose of him.
Narrator: So Haman went to the gallows that he had prepared for Mordecai, and the king took the ring he had given to Haman and gave it instead to Mordecai and set him in the place that had been Haman’s. And Esther spoke again to the king ….
Esther: If it pleases the king and if it seems right, let an order be written to stop the destruction of the Jews across the kingdom. For how can I bear to see the calamity that is coming on my people? How can I bear to see the destruction of my kindred?
King Ahasuerus: (to Mordecai) See, I have put you in the place that was Haman’s because he plotted to destroy the Jews. You may write as you please in the king’s name and seal the order with the king’s ring.
Narrator: In every province and in every city, the king’s command came, and there was gladness and joy among the Jews and they proclaimed a festival and a holiday.
Sermon by Torin Eikler
Esther Matthew 15:21-28
Purim is an interesting religious festival, and if you ever get an invitation to join in the celebrations, I strongly suggest you accept. In the United States, it is something like a New Year’s party crossed with a costume ball. There is lots of noise and children especially play dress up as characters from the story.
In Israel, it’s a good deal more rowdy – more like Mardi Gras in New Orleans. People take sweet breads and other treats to neighbors and friends. There are parades and street parties with blasting music. The entire story of Esther (which is about twice as long as we heard today) is read two times – once at sundown and once at sunup – and committed celebrators stay up until the second reading is completed. Each time Mordecai or Esther are mentioned there is a cheer. Each time Haman speaks, everyone starts making noise; yelling, blowing horns or whistles, swinging rattles, and beating on drums in an effort to drown out the words of the “enemy of the Jews.” And, … there is even a scriptural injunction to imbibe a good deal of alcohol. Tradition says one should be so drunk by morning that one can no longer tell the difference between Mordecai and Haman. (If you do attend a celebration, you might want to hold off on that part.)
I was introduced to the festival of Purim while Carrie and I were in seminary. A few of the Jewish students on Earlham College’s campus worked for us at the Co-op, and they invited us to join them one year. Being a school sponsored group celebrating on campus with under-aged students, there was no alcohol, and being late twenty/early thirty-somethings, Carrie and I did not stay for the morning reading. But we did have a lot of fun, and I remember wondering why Christians (at least in the traditions I have experienced) don’t tend to let loose during religious celebrations in the same way.
Some people do have quite a lot of fun at Christmas or at Easter, and there are festivals on Saint’s days in some other countries, but in the Western world, there is no Christian holiday that we all mark with such a celebration. Even our communion celebrations are muted with just small sip of wine received in a muted atmosphere and not even that in many churches. Most often, it seems, we are sober-faced as well as sober. Where is the joy? Where is the grateful abandon of a community rejoicing in salvation and the richness of life renewed? Largely, it seems, forgotten or locked away for fear of impropriety.
Maybe things would be different if we had been brought back from the brink of annihilation. Maybe if Constantine had order that all Christians – man, woman, and child – be put to the sword before making Christianity the state religion. Maybe then we would dress up and dance in the streets to mark the day that we were saved from oblivion.
But it didn’t happen that way. Rome embraced Christianity – at least to some extent – and we eventually became the power behind the throne of many countries. And, eventually, along with the imperial power and all its trappings, Christianity has adopted an imperial attitude toward those outside its control, ignoring them, conquering them, and even seeking to wipe them out when “necessary” – that is when we felt they threatened our domination or showed too little respect for our power and our station. Sound like anyone we know?
In the August 16th issue of Newsweek, Lisa Miller wrote about the current discussion concerning a mosque scheduled to be built a few blocks from the site of the World Trade Centers. Imbedded in the article were three telling photographs of protesters holding signs that read:
“Stop scapegoating all Muslims for 9/11,”
“Don’t glorify the murders of 3,000… No 9/11 Victory Mosque,”
and, simply, “Islam kills.”
These pictures are meant to characterize the two different approaches taken by the women interviewed in the article. Both women lost sons in the attack on the Trade Centers. One, Sally Regenhard, has responded to the proposed mosque with anger and disbelief. She feels that the idea of the Muslim religious center is not only insensitive but a downright provocation that stabs at the heart of all Americans, especially those who lost loved ones in the attack. Though she does not advocate violence or any kind of persecution against Muslims, her voice has become one of those quoted by others who do, and she feels that they have a right to the anger they are expressing if not the way they propose to express it.
The other, Adele Welty, has responded controversy over the mosque by becoming a voice for tolerance and moderation. In her articles and interviews, she has repeated sought to remind Americans that those who are building the mosque are not responsible for the 9/11 attack, and that many of them lost loved ones too. The language of fear and anger that is being used, she says, goads us into curtailing the freedoms of others and leads to violence that we only live to regret. And, if the recent verbal attacks and the attempts at physical assault on those who are at the heart of the building project are any indication, she may well be right.
In one way, it is not surprising that Americans – who are largely Christian – are responding to the mosque in this way. We have all been deeply wounded whether we were directly affected by the September 11th attacks or not, and as Kathleen Parker pointed out in the Dominion Post’s Op-Ed section on Thursday, it was not wise or considerate of the Muslim community in Manhattan to go ahead with their symbolically charged building project without considering the emotional affect on their neighbors. People who are hurt or badly scared often react with anger and violence when their wounds are poked – even years after the events that scarred them. Jesus, himself, responded to the Canaanite woman with a disdain that had been harbored by his culture for hundreds of years – a disdain that would have cost the life of her son if she had not refused to be silenced.
We enjoyed the drama played out before us this morning, and it is fun to boo the villain and cheer the hero. But, the story of Esther is anything but funny – genocide just barely prevented and a vengeful death. I wonder if part of your laughter, like mine, was a bit … uncomfortable … a bit nervous because something about the characters (the ones we don’t like) hit a little too close to home. Did you find Esther’s courage? Did you find the king’s anger? Haman’s pride? Mordecai’s sense of relish at the defeat of his enemy?
It seems to be in our nature – whether we like it or not – to seek vengeance against those we feel have wronged us or at least to stand aside when they are threatened so as to protect our own. Sometimes, when we do so out of pride or envy, we are more like Haman. Sadly Christian history is full of those stories; many of us continue to write them today. I’d like to think that most of us, here, are not those people. We are probably more like the Sally Regenhards. Acting out of our own pain and vulnerability, we act with rashness and speak with sharp tongues, but we don’t really mean the harm we cause. Or, perhaps we are like Mordecai, standing aside as we watch others get “their just desserts.”
But I think we could do better. I believe we are called to do better. I believe that we could become like Adele Welty, speaking the voice of calm and compassion and tolerance into situations ruled by violent, thoughtless passion, speaking out in defense of those who are persecuted. We might even find it within ourselves to follow the path of Esther and risk our own position, our own comfort, … our own safety in order to prevent the suffering of others.
That’s the path Christ followed in the end. It’s the path he leads us down. And we could follow it if only we could find the courage …. If only we could find the courage.
Esther
Narrator: After these things, when the anger of King Ahasuerus had abated, he remembered Vashti and what she had done and what had been decreed against her. Then the king passed and edict:
King Ahasuerus: “Let beautiful young virgins be sought out for the king. And let all the beautiful young virgins be brought to the royal harem and be put under the custody of Hegai, who is in charge of the women. And let the girl who pleases the king become queen instead of Vashti.
Narrator: Now, there was a Jew in the royal city whose name was Mordecai son of Jair son of Shimei son of Kish. Mordecai had raised Esther, for when her father and mother died, he adopted her as his own daughter. Esther was beautiful. So when the king’s edict was proclaimed, Esther was taken into the king’s palace and put in custody of Hegai, who had charge of the women.
Esther was admired by all who saw her, and when she was taken to King Ahasuerus, the king loved Esther more than all the others, and he set the royal crown on her head and made her queen. Then the king gave a great banquet, and granted a holiday to the provinces, and gave many gifts.
In those days, while Mordecai was sitting at the king’s gate, two of the king’s servants, Bigthan and Teresh, conspired to assassinate the king. But the Mordecai overheard their plan, and he told it to Queen Esther, and Esther told the king in the name of Mordecai. When the affair was investigated and found to be so, both the men were hanged on the gallows. It was recorded in the book of records in the presence of the king.
A little while later, King Ahasuerus promoted Haman son of Hammedatha to be his closest advisor and gave him the king’s ring. And all the king’s servants bowed down when Haman went by, for that was what the king had commanded. But Mordecai did not bow down. When Haman saw that Mordecai did not bow down to him, Haman was infuriated. So, having been told who Mordecai’s people were, Haman plotted to destroy all the Jews throughout the whole kingdom.
When Mordecai learned all that had been done, he tore his clothes and put on sackcloth and ashes, and went through the city, wailing with a loud and bitter cry. Then Esther sent a messenger to Mordecai to learn what was happening and why. The messenger did as Esther wished, and Mordecai told him …
Mordecai: Tell Esther that Haman is trying to destroy all the Jews and to wipe them off the face of the earth just because I refused to bow down to anyone other than the Lord our God. The queen must go before the king and beg for her people to be spared, for she, too, is a Jew.
Narrator: The messenger told all of this to Esther, and Esther sent him back with a reply.
Esther: Everyone knows that if any man or woman goes before the king without being called, they are to be put to death. Only if the king holds out the golden scepter to someone, may that person live. I myself have not been called by the king for thirty days.
Mordecai: Esther, Do not think that in the king’s palace you will escape any more than all the other Jews. For if you keep silence at such a time as this, deliverance will come from someone else, but you and your father’s family will perish. Who knows? Perhaps you have come to royal dignity for just such a time as this.
Esther: Go, gather all the Jews to be found in the city, and hold a fast on my behalf. Don’t eat or drink for three days and three nights. I and my maids will also fast as you do, and after that I will go to the king, though it is against the law. If I perish, I perish.”
Narrator: Esther then went away and did everything as Esther had ordered him.
On the third day Esther put on her royal robes and stood in the court opposite the king’s throne. As soon as the king saw Queen Esther standing in the court, he held out the golden scepter that was in his hand, and Esther went and touched the top of the scepter.
King Ahasuerus: What is it, Queen Esther? What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: If it pleases the king, let the king and Haman come today to a banquet that I have prepared for the king.
King Ahasuerus: Bring Haman quickly, so that we may do as Esther desires.
Narrator: So the king and Haman came to the banquet that Esther had prepared, and the king said to Esther….
King Ahasuerus: What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: This is my request … If I have won the king’s favor, and if it pleases the king to grant fulfill my request, let the king and Haman come tomorrow to the banquet that I will prepare for them, and then I will do as the king has said.
Narrator: Haman went out that day happy and in good spirits, but when he saw Modercai in the king’s gate, he got angry. He went home and sent for his friends and his wife.
Haman: (To the congregation) Look at me. How great a man am I?! I have been made the advisor of the king. I am filthy rich with thousands and thousands of talents in the bank. And I have many strong, smart, and obedient children to make me proud. Even Queen Esther let no one but myself come with the king to the banquet that she prepared. Tomorrow also I am invited by her, together with the king. Yet all this does me no good so long as I see the Jew Mordecai sitting at the king’s gate.
Narrator: Then his wife and all his friends said to him, “Let a gallows fifty cubits high be made, and in the morning tell the king to have Mordecai hanged on it; then go with the king to the banquet in good spirits.” This advice pleased Haman, and he had the gallows made.
On that night King Ahasuerus could not sleep, and he gave orders to bring the book of records. They were read to the king, and he remembered how Mordecai had told him about the two men who had conspired to assassinate him.
King Ahasuerus: What reward has been given to Mordecai to honor his service?
Narrator: The servant who attended him said …
Attendant: Nothing has been done for him.
King Ahasuerus: Who is in the court?
Attendant: Haman is there, standing in the court.
King Ahasuerus: Let him come in.
Narrator: So Haman came in.
King Ahasuerus: What shall be done for the man whom the king wishes to honor?
Haman: (to him/herself) Whom would the king wish to honor more than me?
(to the king) Let the king’s own royal robes be brought and one of the king’s horses with a royal crown on its head. Let the robes and the horse be handed over to one of the king’s most noble officials. Let him put the robes on the man whom the king wishes to honor, and lead that man on horseback through the open square of the city, proclaiming before him: ‘This is how the king shows his gratitude.’
King Ahasuerus: Quickly, take the robes and the horse, and do exactly as you have said to Mordecai.
Narrator: So Haman took the robes and the horse, dressed Mordecai, and led him on horseback through the open square of the city, proclaiming,
Haman: This is how the king shows his gratitude.
Narrator: Then Esther returned to the king’s gate, but Haman hurried to his house, with his head covered in shame and anger. When Haman told his wife and all his friends everything that had happened to him, they said to him, “If Mordecai is of the Jewish people, you will not prevail against him, but will surely fall before him.”
While they were still talking with him, the king’s eunuchs arrived and hurried Haman off to the banquet that Esther had prepared. So the king and Haman went in to feast with Queen Esther on the second day, and the king again said to Esther,
King Ahasuerus: What is it, Queen Esther? What is your request? Whatever you want, even half of my kingdom, I will give it to you.
Esther: If I have won your favor, O king, and if it pleases the king, let my life and the lives of my people be spared—that is my request. For we have been condemned to be wiped out. If we had been sold merely as slaves, I would have held my peace, but no one can make up for this with mere money.”
King Ahasuerus: Who has done this horrible thing?
Esther: There he is – it is Haman!
Narrator: The king rose from the feast in anger and went into the palace garden, but Haman stayed to beg his life from Queen Esther. When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet hall, Haman was grasping the feet of the queen, and the king said
King Ahasuerus: Will he even assault the queen in my own house?!
Narrator: Then one of the servants in attendance on the king, said,
Servant: Look, the very gallows that Haman has prepared for Mordecai, whose word saved the king, stands at Haman’s house, fifty cubits high.
King Ahasuerus: Take him there and dispose of him.
Narrator: So Haman went to the gallows that he had prepared for Mordecai, and the king took the ring he had given to Haman and gave it instead to Mordecai and set him in the place that had been Haman’s. And Esther spoke again to the king ….
Esther: If it pleases the king and if it seems right, let an order be written to stop the destruction of the Jews across the kingdom. For how can I bear to see the calamity that is coming on my people? How can I bear to see the destruction of my kindred?
King Ahasuerus: (to Mordecai) See, I have put you in the place that was Haman’s because he plotted to destroy the Jews. You may write as you please in the king’s name and seal the order with the king’s ring.
Narrator: In every province and in every city, the king’s command came, and there was gladness and joy among the Jews and they proclaimed a festival and a holiday.
Sermon by Torin Eikler
Esther Matthew 15:21-28
Purim is an interesting religious festival, and if you ever get an invitation to join in the celebrations, I strongly suggest you accept. In the United States, it is something like a New Year’s party crossed with a costume ball. There is lots of noise and children especially play dress up as characters from the story.
In Israel, it’s a good deal more rowdy – more like Mardi Gras in New Orleans. People take sweet breads and other treats to neighbors and friends. There are parades and street parties with blasting music. The entire story of Esther (which is about twice as long as we heard today) is read two times – once at sundown and once at sunup – and committed celebrators stay up until the second reading is completed. Each time Mordecai or Esther are mentioned there is a cheer. Each time Haman speaks, everyone starts making noise; yelling, blowing horns or whistles, swinging rattles, and beating on drums in an effort to drown out the words of the “enemy of the Jews.” And, … there is even a scriptural injunction to imbibe a good deal of alcohol. Tradition says one should be so drunk by morning that one can no longer tell the difference between Mordecai and Haman. (If you do attend a celebration, you might want to hold off on that part.)
I was introduced to the festival of Purim while Carrie and I were in seminary. A few of the Jewish students on Earlham College’s campus worked for us at the Co-op, and they invited us to join them one year. Being a school sponsored group celebrating on campus with under-aged students, there was no alcohol, and being late twenty/early thirty-somethings, Carrie and I did not stay for the morning reading. But we did have a lot of fun, and I remember wondering why Christians (at least in the traditions I have experienced) don’t tend to let loose during religious celebrations in the same way.
Some people do have quite a lot of fun at Christmas or at Easter, and there are festivals on Saint’s days in some other countries, but in the Western world, there is no Christian holiday that we all mark with such a celebration. Even our communion celebrations are muted with just small sip of wine received in a muted atmosphere and not even that in many churches. Most often, it seems, we are sober-faced as well as sober. Where is the joy? Where is the grateful abandon of a community rejoicing in salvation and the richness of life renewed? Largely, it seems, forgotten or locked away for fear of impropriety.
Maybe things would be different if we had been brought back from the brink of annihilation. Maybe if Constantine had order that all Christians – man, woman, and child – be put to the sword before making Christianity the state religion. Maybe then we would dress up and dance in the streets to mark the day that we were saved from oblivion.
But it didn’t happen that way. Rome embraced Christianity – at least to some extent – and we eventually became the power behind the throne of many countries. And, eventually, along with the imperial power and all its trappings, Christianity has adopted an imperial attitude toward those outside its control, ignoring them, conquering them, and even seeking to wipe them out when “necessary” – that is when we felt they threatened our domination or showed too little respect for our power and our station. Sound like anyone we know?
In the August 16th issue of Newsweek, Lisa Miller wrote about the current discussion concerning a mosque scheduled to be built a few blocks from the site of the World Trade Centers. Imbedded in the article were three telling photographs of protesters holding signs that read:
“Stop scapegoating all Muslims for 9/11,”
“Don’t glorify the murders of 3,000… No 9/11 Victory Mosque,”
and, simply, “Islam kills.”
These pictures are meant to characterize the two different approaches taken by the women interviewed in the article. Both women lost sons in the attack on the Trade Centers. One, Sally Regenhard, has responded to the proposed mosque with anger and disbelief. She feels that the idea of the Muslim religious center is not only insensitive but a downright provocation that stabs at the heart of all Americans, especially those who lost loved ones in the attack. Though she does not advocate violence or any kind of persecution against Muslims, her voice has become one of those quoted by others who do, and she feels that they have a right to the anger they are expressing if not the way they propose to express it.
The other, Adele Welty, has responded controversy over the mosque by becoming a voice for tolerance and moderation. In her articles and interviews, she has repeated sought to remind Americans that those who are building the mosque are not responsible for the 9/11 attack, and that many of them lost loved ones too. The language of fear and anger that is being used, she says, goads us into curtailing the freedoms of others and leads to violence that we only live to regret. And, if the recent verbal attacks and the attempts at physical assault on those who are at the heart of the building project are any indication, she may well be right.
In one way, it is not surprising that Americans – who are largely Christian – are responding to the mosque in this way. We have all been deeply wounded whether we were directly affected by the September 11th attacks or not, and as Kathleen Parker pointed out in the Dominion Post’s Op-Ed section on Thursday, it was not wise or considerate of the Muslim community in Manhattan to go ahead with their symbolically charged building project without considering the emotional affect on their neighbors. People who are hurt or badly scared often react with anger and violence when their wounds are poked – even years after the events that scarred them. Jesus, himself, responded to the Canaanite woman with a disdain that had been harbored by his culture for hundreds of years – a disdain that would have cost the life of her son if she had not refused to be silenced.
We enjoyed the drama played out before us this morning, and it is fun to boo the villain and cheer the hero. But, the story of Esther is anything but funny – genocide just barely prevented and a vengeful death. I wonder if part of your laughter, like mine, was a bit … uncomfortable … a bit nervous because something about the characters (the ones we don’t like) hit a little too close to home. Did you find Esther’s courage? Did you find the king’s anger? Haman’s pride? Mordecai’s sense of relish at the defeat of his enemy?
It seems to be in our nature – whether we like it or not – to seek vengeance against those we feel have wronged us or at least to stand aside when they are threatened so as to protect our own. Sometimes, when we do so out of pride or envy, we are more like Haman. Sadly Christian history is full of those stories; many of us continue to write them today. I’d like to think that most of us, here, are not those people. We are probably more like the Sally Regenhards. Acting out of our own pain and vulnerability, we act with rashness and speak with sharp tongues, but we don’t really mean the harm we cause. Or, perhaps we are like Mordecai, standing aside as we watch others get “their just desserts.”
But I think we could do better. I believe we are called to do better. I believe that we could become like Adele Welty, speaking the voice of calm and compassion and tolerance into situations ruled by violent, thoughtless passion, speaking out in defense of those who are persecuted. We might even find it within ourselves to follow the path of Esther and risk our own position, our own comfort, … our own safety in order to prevent the suffering of others.
That’s the path Christ followed in the end. It’s the path he leads us down. And we could follow it if only we could find the courage …. If only we could find the courage.
Sunday, August 1, 2010
Flying After Jesus
Sermon by Torin Eikler
Daniel 3 Luke 9:23-26
Have you ever been to the circus and watched trapeze artists in action? I remember the one time that I went to the circus as a child. It was a big one, and most of my memories are fuzzy with the over stimulation and adrenaline of over-sugared in the midst of 5,000 on-lookers. But I do remember watching the trapeze troupe swing back and forth and summersault through the air during the eternal moments between letting go and catching hold. And with absolute clarity, I remember the way that my stomach tensed up when one of them missed a catch and fell toward certain death only to be caught by the safety net that I hadn’t noticed before. Ever since that day, I have been fascinated by the men and women who continue the long tradition of astounding audiences by flying through the air.
As it turns out, I am not alone in this fascination. Henri Nouwen, the catholic priest and author that we mention every so often, was also a fan. In fact, he was so intrigued by trapeze artists that he befriended a troupe of trapezists called the Flying Rodleighs, and he was able to ask a question that I’ve always wondered about: how do “flyers,” as they’re called, manage to catch the hands of the other person on their swing. In his book, Servants, Misfits, and Martyrs: Saints and their Stories, James C. Howell recounts the response he received from the chief of the Flying Rodleighs.
The secret is that the flyer does nothing and the catcher does everything. When I fly to Joe, I have simply to stretch out my arms and hands and wait for him to catch me and pull me safely over the apron behind the catchbar…. The worst thing the flyer can do is to try to catch the catcher. I’m not supposed to catch Joe. It’s Joe’s task to catch me…. A flyer must fly, and a catcher must catch, and the flyer must trust, with outstretched arms, that his catcher will be there for him.”
While the trapeze artist clearly meant this to be a simple explanation of his technique, I find it to quite an elegant description of the life of faith. As people of faith we are all flyers. It is our job to swing off the platform and let go of the bar, risking a fall. And we must trust, with outstretched arms, that God will catch us as we seek to follow our guide and savior.
Enter Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, three young men from ruling families of Israel taken to the court of King Nebuchadnezzar to serve as court wise men as well as “hostages” ensuring the cooperation of the newly subjugated nation. Over the course of three or four years, they lived with the wise men of the Babylonian court along with their friend Daniel, offering advice and interpreting signs at the king’s behest. Eventually, they were appointed as governors of one province of the empire as a reward for interpreting a particularly troubling dream. A short time later, the king passed an edict commanding all his subjects to bow down and worship a golden statue on pain of death, and the three young men found themselves swinging precariously over a long, long drop into the fire.
You all know the rest of the story. The three men refused to worship anyone or anything other than their own God, holding firm even as they were thrown into a furnace so hot that their executioners were died just getting close enough to them flying. And fly they did, trusting, with arms outstretched that God would be there to catch them.
That the men survived does not stop the story from qualifying them as martyrs. Martyrs are no more or less than people who hold to their faith even if it means that they will die. But martyr stories are more than just tales that we tell for inspiration and encouragement. They are also stories that are intended to promote action and embolden faith on the part of listeners. In other words, the story of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, according to commentator Frederick J. Murphy, is not just a show of faith but a call to active, non-violent resistance to worldly power and symbols of colonization, and that’s something that we should know more than a little bit about.
Anabaptists have been resisting the power of colonialism, whether it be found in secular or church bureaucracies, for 500 years or more. It is what we were born to do in as much as our spiritual ancestors acted in direct defiance of both government and church when they baptized one another, hurling themselves into persecution and death to follow the path of discipleship … flying, arms outstretched, toward Jesus on the strength of their faith.
They, too, are martyrs – those who were burned, hung, or drowned as well as those who survived, and their stories invite us to the same active resistance. They call us to another way of living – a way that seeks follows the teachings and example of Jesus. Their legacy is ensconced in the way Mennonites and Brethren continue to characterize themselves: as disciples of Christ who seek continue his work together, reject violence, and strive for lives of simplicity lived in harmony with the rest of humanity and all of creation. … And, there are many of us who claim that heritage … that identity with our lives as well as our voices.
Most of us resist the violence of the world even in difficult situations, and there are some sisters and brothers who go farther. They seek not just to resist but to transform situations of injustice and oppression by applying the same discipline and self-sacrifice that armies devote to war to non-violent peace-making. Together they have formed an organization called Christian Peacemaker Teams that supports members as they confront systems of domination.
Where communities are experiencing oppression and the concrete threat of violence and death, CPTers step into the midst of the conflict and try to promote relationship and compassion in the place of brokenness and hatred by their own example. There are stories of stepping in front of loaded guns, accompanying people through dangerous territory or check-points where soldiers push them to the ground and shoot into the air above their heads, and sitting together in prayer as the military shells the neighborhood. Often, the response from both sides is anger and confusion, and many CPTers have been arrested, held in jail, deported, or banned by the powers they confront. One man, Tom Fox, was even killed after three months of being held hostage by a militant group in Iraq.
Others take “safer” paths, though those ways require sacrifice as well. Some, like our friends in Church Communities International (which some of you will know as the Bruderhof) choose to give up personal ownership and a measure of independence in order to embrace the richness of community. Others give up family life in order to dedicate themselves to Christ and the work of the Church. Still others choose the way of extreme simplicity, living in a way that neither abuses the earth nor supports inequity in the workplace.
Cliff and Arlene Kindy live in a small house on a farm in Northern Indiana. In their commitment to following Jesus, they have decided to live under the poverty level. They do this, in part, to avoid paying taxes that support the military, but they are also trying to live in solidarity with people across the country and the world who do not have the same advantages they do.
Once, when Arlene was explaining some of this to me, she told me that she had repeated chosen not to accept jobs as a teacher though that is her training and background. When I asked her why, she said that it wasn’t that the income would put them above the poverty line or that she disagreed with the celebration of violence in the curriculum. It was because there were other people as qualified as she who make much, much less than she would have, and she didn’t want to support a system with that kind of inequity. She had offered several times to teach for what she felt was a more just level of pay, but no one would hire her. So, she continued to work in her organic vegetable garden until she could find a position that would meet her criteria.
“If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me.” It’s a verse that we have all heard so many times that I wonder if we pay attention to it anymore. I wonder if we think about what it is really asking us to do.
If you’re anything like me, you get caught up in cross imagery that is so often the focus of sermons on this text. You begin thinking about self-sacrifice, about martyrdom, and about self-denial in the spiritual, eternal sense. But, when was the last time you heard … really heard the end of the sentence: “take up their cross daily and follow me?”
What does it mean to follow Jesus … daily? I suppose there is no way around the fact that it could mean risking death for our faith, but how often does that come into any of our lives. And if we ever were called to sacrifice in the way Tom Fox did, that would be a once in a lifetime moment … not an every day practice.
Following Jesus is not just about the extreme of martyrdom which I think we admire and abhor in just about equal measure. It is also about our everyday choices: about how they grow out of love and compassion for others … or not, about how they resist the inequities and abuses in our world … or not, about how they help others to experience the Kingdom promise of wholeness and new life … or not. That doesn’t necessarily mean that there is any less self-denial, any less sacrifice involved though.
As people of faith and as Anabaptists, we are all called to make our lives speak about what is important to us just as loudly as our voices. We each have things that we need to give up, and we are each called to particular acts of compassion and love. What that denial is, what those actions are grows out of our own particular background. We may not all make the choices like Arlene’s, but each of us has passions born of our faith and experience. Whatever your passions are, where ever your faith leads you, we are all called to take up our cross daily and follow Jesus.
We are all called to let go of the bar and fly toward Christ.
Daniel 3 Luke 9:23-26
Have you ever been to the circus and watched trapeze artists in action? I remember the one time that I went to the circus as a child. It was a big one, and most of my memories are fuzzy with the over stimulation and adrenaline of over-sugared in the midst of 5,000 on-lookers. But I do remember watching the trapeze troupe swing back and forth and summersault through the air during the eternal moments between letting go and catching hold. And with absolute clarity, I remember the way that my stomach tensed up when one of them missed a catch and fell toward certain death only to be caught by the safety net that I hadn’t noticed before. Ever since that day, I have been fascinated by the men and women who continue the long tradition of astounding audiences by flying through the air.
As it turns out, I am not alone in this fascination. Henri Nouwen, the catholic priest and author that we mention every so often, was also a fan. In fact, he was so intrigued by trapeze artists that he befriended a troupe of trapezists called the Flying Rodleighs, and he was able to ask a question that I’ve always wondered about: how do “flyers,” as they’re called, manage to catch the hands of the other person on their swing. In his book, Servants, Misfits, and Martyrs: Saints and their Stories, James C. Howell recounts the response he received from the chief of the Flying Rodleighs.
The secret is that the flyer does nothing and the catcher does everything. When I fly to Joe, I have simply to stretch out my arms and hands and wait for him to catch me and pull me safely over the apron behind the catchbar…. The worst thing the flyer can do is to try to catch the catcher. I’m not supposed to catch Joe. It’s Joe’s task to catch me…. A flyer must fly, and a catcher must catch, and the flyer must trust, with outstretched arms, that his catcher will be there for him.”
While the trapeze artist clearly meant this to be a simple explanation of his technique, I find it to quite an elegant description of the life of faith. As people of faith we are all flyers. It is our job to swing off the platform and let go of the bar, risking a fall. And we must trust, with outstretched arms, that God will catch us as we seek to follow our guide and savior.
Enter Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, three young men from ruling families of Israel taken to the court of King Nebuchadnezzar to serve as court wise men as well as “hostages” ensuring the cooperation of the newly subjugated nation. Over the course of three or four years, they lived with the wise men of the Babylonian court along with their friend Daniel, offering advice and interpreting signs at the king’s behest. Eventually, they were appointed as governors of one province of the empire as a reward for interpreting a particularly troubling dream. A short time later, the king passed an edict commanding all his subjects to bow down and worship a golden statue on pain of death, and the three young men found themselves swinging precariously over a long, long drop into the fire.
You all know the rest of the story. The three men refused to worship anyone or anything other than their own God, holding firm even as they were thrown into a furnace so hot that their executioners were died just getting close enough to them flying. And fly they did, trusting, with arms outstretched that God would be there to catch them.
That the men survived does not stop the story from qualifying them as martyrs. Martyrs are no more or less than people who hold to their faith even if it means that they will die. But martyr stories are more than just tales that we tell for inspiration and encouragement. They are also stories that are intended to promote action and embolden faith on the part of listeners. In other words, the story of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, according to commentator Frederick J. Murphy, is not just a show of faith but a call to active, non-violent resistance to worldly power and symbols of colonization, and that’s something that we should know more than a little bit about.
Anabaptists have been resisting the power of colonialism, whether it be found in secular or church bureaucracies, for 500 years or more. It is what we were born to do in as much as our spiritual ancestors acted in direct defiance of both government and church when they baptized one another, hurling themselves into persecution and death to follow the path of discipleship … flying, arms outstretched, toward Jesus on the strength of their faith.
They, too, are martyrs – those who were burned, hung, or drowned as well as those who survived, and their stories invite us to the same active resistance. They call us to another way of living – a way that seeks follows the teachings and example of Jesus. Their legacy is ensconced in the way Mennonites and Brethren continue to characterize themselves: as disciples of Christ who seek continue his work together, reject violence, and strive for lives of simplicity lived in harmony with the rest of humanity and all of creation. … And, there are many of us who claim that heritage … that identity with our lives as well as our voices.
Most of us resist the violence of the world even in difficult situations, and there are some sisters and brothers who go farther. They seek not just to resist but to transform situations of injustice and oppression by applying the same discipline and self-sacrifice that armies devote to war to non-violent peace-making. Together they have formed an organization called Christian Peacemaker Teams that supports members as they confront systems of domination.
Where communities are experiencing oppression and the concrete threat of violence and death, CPTers step into the midst of the conflict and try to promote relationship and compassion in the place of brokenness and hatred by their own example. There are stories of stepping in front of loaded guns, accompanying people through dangerous territory or check-points where soldiers push them to the ground and shoot into the air above their heads, and sitting together in prayer as the military shells the neighborhood. Often, the response from both sides is anger and confusion, and many CPTers have been arrested, held in jail, deported, or banned by the powers they confront. One man, Tom Fox, was even killed after three months of being held hostage by a militant group in Iraq.
Others take “safer” paths, though those ways require sacrifice as well. Some, like our friends in Church Communities International (which some of you will know as the Bruderhof) choose to give up personal ownership and a measure of independence in order to embrace the richness of community. Others give up family life in order to dedicate themselves to Christ and the work of the Church. Still others choose the way of extreme simplicity, living in a way that neither abuses the earth nor supports inequity in the workplace.
Cliff and Arlene Kindy live in a small house on a farm in Northern Indiana. In their commitment to following Jesus, they have decided to live under the poverty level. They do this, in part, to avoid paying taxes that support the military, but they are also trying to live in solidarity with people across the country and the world who do not have the same advantages they do.
Once, when Arlene was explaining some of this to me, she told me that she had repeated chosen not to accept jobs as a teacher though that is her training and background. When I asked her why, she said that it wasn’t that the income would put them above the poverty line or that she disagreed with the celebration of violence in the curriculum. It was because there were other people as qualified as she who make much, much less than she would have, and she didn’t want to support a system with that kind of inequity. She had offered several times to teach for what she felt was a more just level of pay, but no one would hire her. So, she continued to work in her organic vegetable garden until she could find a position that would meet her criteria.
“If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me.” It’s a verse that we have all heard so many times that I wonder if we pay attention to it anymore. I wonder if we think about what it is really asking us to do.
If you’re anything like me, you get caught up in cross imagery that is so often the focus of sermons on this text. You begin thinking about self-sacrifice, about martyrdom, and about self-denial in the spiritual, eternal sense. But, when was the last time you heard … really heard the end of the sentence: “take up their cross daily and follow me?”
What does it mean to follow Jesus … daily? I suppose there is no way around the fact that it could mean risking death for our faith, but how often does that come into any of our lives. And if we ever were called to sacrifice in the way Tom Fox did, that would be a once in a lifetime moment … not an every day practice.
Following Jesus is not just about the extreme of martyrdom which I think we admire and abhor in just about equal measure. It is also about our everyday choices: about how they grow out of love and compassion for others … or not, about how they resist the inequities and abuses in our world … or not, about how they help others to experience the Kingdom promise of wholeness and new life … or not. That doesn’t necessarily mean that there is any less self-denial, any less sacrifice involved though.
As people of faith and as Anabaptists, we are all called to make our lives speak about what is important to us just as loudly as our voices. We each have things that we need to give up, and we are each called to particular acts of compassion and love. What that denial is, what those actions are grows out of our own particular background. We may not all make the choices like Arlene’s, but each of us has passions born of our faith and experience. Whatever your passions are, where ever your faith leads you, we are all called to take up our cross daily and follow Jesus.
We are all called to let go of the bar and fly toward Christ.
Sunday, July 25, 2010
Jonah, Jesus, and Judgment: Part Two
sermon by Carrie Eikler
John 8:2-11, Jonah 3&4
scripture readings from Jonah 3&4 and John 8:2-11. (This was read in two voices, one reading from Jonah, the other from John. I found it drew interesting parallels with the emotion of the "angered" with the reaction from God/Jesus)
The word of the LORD came to Jonah a second time, saying, 2“Get up, go to Nineveh, that great city, and proclaim to it the message that I tell you.” 3So Jonah set out and went to Nineveh, according to the word of the LORD. Now Nineveh was an exceedingly large city, a three days’ walk across. 4Jonah began to go into the city, going a day’s walk. And he cried out, “Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!”
Early in the morning [Jesus] came again to the temple. All the people came to him and he sat down and began to teach them. 3The scribes and the Pharisees brought a woman who had been caught in adultery; and making her stand before all of them, 4they said to him, “Teacher, this woman was caught in the very act of committing adultery. 5Now in the law, Moses commanded us to stone such women. Now what do you say?” 6They said this to test him, so that they might have some charge to bring against him.
And the people of Nineveh believed God; they proclaimed a fast, and everyone, great and small, put on sackcloth. 10When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil ways, God changed his mind about the calamity that he had said he would bring upon them; and he did not do it.
Jesus bent down and wrote with his finger on the ground. 7When they kept on questioning him, he straightened up and said to them, “Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.” 8And once again he bent down and wrote on the ground
But this was very displeasing to Jonah, and he became angry. 2He prayed to the LORD and said, “O LORD! Is not this what I said while I was still in my own country? That is why I fled to Tarshish at the beginning; for I knew that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to relent from punishing. 3And now, O LORD, please take my life from me, for it is better for me to die than to live.” 4And the LORD said, “Is it right for you to be angry?”
When they heard it, they went away, one by one, beginning with the elders; and Jesus was left alone with the woman standing before him. 10Jesus straightened up and said to her, “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?” 11She said, “No one, sir.” And Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go your way, and from now on do not sin again.”
Last week we began with the story of AJ Jacobs, a New Yorker, editor of the magazine Esquire, and secular Jew who decided to take on the wild and wonderful Biblical world. He did this by actually attempting to live by its laws and prescriptions literally for one full year. As we discovered last week, this meant doing what many of us would never dream of doing: physically stoning someone the Bible says to condemn. In Jacobs’ case, he lightly pebbled a 70-year old adulterer he met while sitting on a park bench.
And if you remember, he admitted to feeling a sensation of power and righteousness in the act, while also feeling morally stunted at the same time. We began poking at our sense of righteousness whenever we pass judgment: whether we hurl verbal and emotional stones at people—like the Pharisees wished to throw physical stones—or if it is criticism of individuals or groups or situations made from a safe distance—like Jonah perched outside of Ninevah complaining to God about sparing the lives of the heathen Ninevites.
If you were like me, you felt more sensitive to your own tendency to judge this week. I paid attention to what situations began drawing out judgment in me, and to be honest, I didn’t really realize what I was doing until I was in the midst of my judgment: talking back to the radio, or rolling my eyes at someone I saw in the grocery store. But at least I was recognizing it. Did you recognize it?
My humble hypothesis from last week, is that our delight in judgment and criticism comes from a place within us that feels deep pain, and at the same time deep passion. Last week we talked about the pain and how it enters our lives when we think that life is “survival of the fittest …” that we must be on top and superior to everyone around us … that until we make the world in our own image, the our neighbors are completely misguided. Like Jonah, we understand that even God’s mercy, especially for others, isn’t a consolation when all we really want is to be right and to be better than.
Pain and passion seems like a dangerous mixture. Yet it can be a joy to discover the passion at the heart of our judgments because we can begin to cultivate the goodness of our passions, rather than allowing them to take us down judgmental paths.
So this is how it worked for me this week. I’m quite passionate between the hour of 5:30 and 6:30pm when it’s my night to cook dinner. Many of you know, I feel passionate about food and cooking, and while I give thanks for that passion, it has shown me one of my major judgments: I judge people who I feel do not appreciate food the way I do.
I have come to have a spiritual relationship with food: preparing it, serving it, eating it, and most of all trying to enjoy it. I think I’m passionate about it because for so long food has been something that I have had a lot of pain attached to. As many women in America have experienced, I’ve been told to fear food. I’ve been conditioned to think of the bad things it can do to me rather than the joyous things it can give me – to look at good food and picture fat thighs. Welcome to being a woman in America.
But in the past few years I have begun to see it differently. I have begun to delight in it. I have begun to let it really feed me. And I hope that any extra fat on my thighs has come from birthing two babies and not my new found love of baking homemade croissants. But it’s true the pain and fear are still there. When the baby weight from Alistair hasn’t fallen off as easily as with Sebastian. When my body just looks differently now than it did before. Those dark fears, those pains come creeping in and there is a head on cage match with my passion.
So rather than dealing with that collision in myself, I project it onto others: those who eat junk food, those who are obese, those who I see lining up at the drive-through at McDonald’s. And I find myself harshly judging. “If people just appreciated food like I do, took the time to prepare good food like I do, had the knowledge, the resources, the background that I do…” and it’s a downward spiral from there.
And since I’m too busy looking down on those people over there, I’m not able to look down at what’s in front of me: Jesus, drawing in the dirt. Can I join him there? When faced with the opportunity to judge, can I crouch down and be a bearer of love, rather than a giver of criticism?
I worry I may have given the impression last week that I would be giving you a quick fix to your judgmentalism today — and I realize that I am completely unqualified to tell you what to do on this matter. But as I’ve thought about it this week, there are some findings can share with you. But first and foremost, it is clear that an attitude of non-judmentalism is kind of like pacifism. It gives the impression of withdrawal, of “not doing” anything. But when we are serious about not judging, we discover it is a very active process.
So this is what I learned from a Mennonite peacemaker, Buddhist meditation, and Lenten devotions.
I heard John Paul Lederach speak at Bethany Seminary when I was a student. Lederach is a Mennonite who currently teaches at Notre Dame, but, more notably, Lederach is a well respected practitioner of international conflict transformation. I was reminded of him and his work when he was featured on NPR’s “Speaking of Faith” a couple weeks ago. And I was struck by how his approach to conflict transformation is relevant to so many aspects of our lives, even helping us drop our stones of judgments.
It involves cultivating, within ourselves, what he calls a “moral imagination.”
According to Lederach, the moral imagination is the capacity to recognize and take advantage of turning points and possibilities present to us in order to venture down unknown paths that create something entirely new. But first and foremost it requires us to see ourselves as part of a web of relationships, one that even includes our enemies … and people or situations we consistently judge.
We need to recognize we are all connected, one organism based on mutuality. It urges us to suspend the polarities of our judgments—moving beyond seeing the world in black and white, recognizing that human situations are more complex than winners and losers, best ideas and worse ideas, right choices and wrong choices. If we can do this, the moral imagination replaces our judgment by showing us surprising opportunities for connection, and unexpected potential for relationships, even in the face of differences.
Isn’t it relationships over polarities that Jesus emphasizes? I think Jesus is exhibiting a bit of moral imagination in our scripture for today. He is recognizing a turning point, a moment of tension where things could go any which way, the possibility of a new outcome, a new reaction, a new heart. In the midst of attack and judgment … when Jesus was invited to judge, he saw a turning point and he simply stopped.
Perhaps that is a good starting point for us. In my studies of Buddhism and in my on again off again yoga practice, I’ve been introduced to a practice called mindfulness. It is, simply put, trying to be absolutely present in the moment. Not dwelling on the past, or anticipating the future. Perhaps practicing mindfulness can help us crouch with Jesus as he writes in the dirt.
So while we’re here, let’s stop ourselves and practice a little – a moment of mindfulness. Take a few moments to think about what, or whom you are very judgmental, or critical, about. Maybe it’s an individual, or a behavior. It might be a group, or a way of thinking, or a belief system. What is that judgment you have? [pause]
Now imagine you encounter that person, that group, or that behavior. And you feel that bubbling of judgment starting to heat up. It shoots from your brain down to your stomach where it ferments for a moment. Then it rises up your throat and comes out in critical or hurtful words.
The first step of applying mindfulness to our judgments starts here, where you recognize what is happening. You notice what is going on, especially the physical sensations. You might notice your chest getting tight, your lips pursing, your brow knitting. I notice I’m rolling my eyes or feel the beginning of a smirk. What is your body doing.?
Now describe what you’re seeing – put into words what is going on that might be causing that sensation. The person in the grocery line has food I don’t approve. The news story is talking about a politician I don’t like. My friend has made bad decisions. But that description is itself a judgment. Practice seeing the person over the problem. Be in the moment with what you are seeing, describing the person you see, not what they’re doing or saying…. I’m looking at the person in front of me in the checkout line. I am watching a news story. I am talking with a friend. Dwell with the image of the person
And if through practice we can get to the point where we see the person rather than the problem, we might be sewing that web together where we would otherwise be cutting it apart. Simply stopping that runaway train of immediate evaluation and snap judgment helps us to be less judgmental people.
Perhaps in some way this is what Jesus was doing. Jesus stopped and wrote in the dirt. We don’t know what he’s wrote, but the act of writing itself was important enough for the author of John to include it. It meant something. Something was happening. Maybe it wasn’t so much what he was writing but what the process of his writing did in the situation.
He confused the process, forced things to stop. He threw everyone off guard and got them to look at themselves instead of the adulteress. He stopped the violent cycle
Now maybe that still seems vague and complex. Maybe it would be more helpful to look at non-judmentalism as a spiritual discipline just like any other. You could apply the spiritual discipline of silence.
This is what Torin and I did last year during Lent when we found our tendency to be judgmental was spinning out of control. We simply practiced silence and stopped giving voice to your judgments. Even if you think them, don’t say them. It can seem simplistic or misguided, but we found that it helped. Often in our sharing our judgments with others (especially if they are not those people we are judging) we are really looking for someone to agree with us that we are better than the person we are judging. If I have the ear of someone else, my judgments become catty, even more hurtful, and I become more and more separated from that web of relationships.
Now, not speaking your judgments doesn’t mean you won’t have them, but like Jesus writing in the dirt, it stops that cycle for a moment—when we actively think that silence is needed, it brings it to our attention that we were about to say something judgmental. We can then look at the judgments mindfully. It allows us to ask questions of our judgments. We can ask ourselves, will this observation build up or tear down? Will I be more connected with the web of relationships, or leave me disconnected? Is this about making me feel superior?
Connectedness, mindfulness, prayer, and silence. That’s a tall order. But I believe it can be worth the work. Jesus gives us an example of mercy, but he also gives us, with stones in hand, a chance to also practice it. He didn’t just give the angry crowd words of non-judgment, he gave them an opportunity to participate in his gospel of mercy. When he says, “Go and sin no more,” it is hard to hear it as a command to the woman without hoping it will touch the ears of those walking away.
Our work at relinquishing judgment, is our living out Christ’s gospel. May the passion overcome the pain as we become bearers of Love.
John 8:2-11, Jonah 3&4
scripture readings from Jonah 3&4 and John 8:2-11. (This was read in two voices, one reading from Jonah, the other from John. I found it drew interesting parallels with the emotion of the "angered" with the reaction from God/Jesus)
The word of the LORD came to Jonah a second time, saying, 2“Get up, go to Nineveh, that great city, and proclaim to it the message that I tell you.” 3So Jonah set out and went to Nineveh, according to the word of the LORD. Now Nineveh was an exceedingly large city, a three days’ walk across. 4Jonah began to go into the city, going a day’s walk. And he cried out, “Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!”
Early in the morning [Jesus] came again to the temple. All the people came to him and he sat down and began to teach them. 3The scribes and the Pharisees brought a woman who had been caught in adultery; and making her stand before all of them, 4they said to him, “Teacher, this woman was caught in the very act of committing adultery. 5Now in the law, Moses commanded us to stone such women. Now what do you say?” 6They said this to test him, so that they might have some charge to bring against him.
And the people of Nineveh believed God; they proclaimed a fast, and everyone, great and small, put on sackcloth. 10When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil ways, God changed his mind about the calamity that he had said he would bring upon them; and he did not do it.
Jesus bent down and wrote with his finger on the ground. 7When they kept on questioning him, he straightened up and said to them, “Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.” 8And once again he bent down and wrote on the ground
But this was very displeasing to Jonah, and he became angry. 2He prayed to the LORD and said, “O LORD! Is not this what I said while I was still in my own country? That is why I fled to Tarshish at the beginning; for I knew that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to relent from punishing. 3And now, O LORD, please take my life from me, for it is better for me to die than to live.” 4And the LORD said, “Is it right for you to be angry?”
When they heard it, they went away, one by one, beginning with the elders; and Jesus was left alone with the woman standing before him. 10Jesus straightened up and said to her, “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?” 11She said, “No one, sir.” And Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go your way, and from now on do not sin again.”
Last week we began with the story of AJ Jacobs, a New Yorker, editor of the magazine Esquire, and secular Jew who decided to take on the wild and wonderful Biblical world. He did this by actually attempting to live by its laws and prescriptions literally for one full year. As we discovered last week, this meant doing what many of us would never dream of doing: physically stoning someone the Bible says to condemn. In Jacobs’ case, he lightly pebbled a 70-year old adulterer he met while sitting on a park bench.
And if you remember, he admitted to feeling a sensation of power and righteousness in the act, while also feeling morally stunted at the same time. We began poking at our sense of righteousness whenever we pass judgment: whether we hurl verbal and emotional stones at people—like the Pharisees wished to throw physical stones—or if it is criticism of individuals or groups or situations made from a safe distance—like Jonah perched outside of Ninevah complaining to God about sparing the lives of the heathen Ninevites.
If you were like me, you felt more sensitive to your own tendency to judge this week. I paid attention to what situations began drawing out judgment in me, and to be honest, I didn’t really realize what I was doing until I was in the midst of my judgment: talking back to the radio, or rolling my eyes at someone I saw in the grocery store. But at least I was recognizing it. Did you recognize it?
My humble hypothesis from last week, is that our delight in judgment and criticism comes from a place within us that feels deep pain, and at the same time deep passion. Last week we talked about the pain and how it enters our lives when we think that life is “survival of the fittest …” that we must be on top and superior to everyone around us … that until we make the world in our own image, the our neighbors are completely misguided. Like Jonah, we understand that even God’s mercy, especially for others, isn’t a consolation when all we really want is to be right and to be better than.
Pain and passion seems like a dangerous mixture. Yet it can be a joy to discover the passion at the heart of our judgments because we can begin to cultivate the goodness of our passions, rather than allowing them to take us down judgmental paths.
So this is how it worked for me this week. I’m quite passionate between the hour of 5:30 and 6:30pm when it’s my night to cook dinner. Many of you know, I feel passionate about food and cooking, and while I give thanks for that passion, it has shown me one of my major judgments: I judge people who I feel do not appreciate food the way I do.
I have come to have a spiritual relationship with food: preparing it, serving it, eating it, and most of all trying to enjoy it. I think I’m passionate about it because for so long food has been something that I have had a lot of pain attached to. As many women in America have experienced, I’ve been told to fear food. I’ve been conditioned to think of the bad things it can do to me rather than the joyous things it can give me – to look at good food and picture fat thighs. Welcome to being a woman in America.
But in the past few years I have begun to see it differently. I have begun to delight in it. I have begun to let it really feed me. And I hope that any extra fat on my thighs has come from birthing two babies and not my new found love of baking homemade croissants. But it’s true the pain and fear are still there. When the baby weight from Alistair hasn’t fallen off as easily as with Sebastian. When my body just looks differently now than it did before. Those dark fears, those pains come creeping in and there is a head on cage match with my passion.
So rather than dealing with that collision in myself, I project it onto others: those who eat junk food, those who are obese, those who I see lining up at the drive-through at McDonald’s. And I find myself harshly judging. “If people just appreciated food like I do, took the time to prepare good food like I do, had the knowledge, the resources, the background that I do…” and it’s a downward spiral from there.
And since I’m too busy looking down on those people over there, I’m not able to look down at what’s in front of me: Jesus, drawing in the dirt. Can I join him there? When faced with the opportunity to judge, can I crouch down and be a bearer of love, rather than a giver of criticism?
I worry I may have given the impression last week that I would be giving you a quick fix to your judgmentalism today — and I realize that I am completely unqualified to tell you what to do on this matter. But as I’ve thought about it this week, there are some findings can share with you. But first and foremost, it is clear that an attitude of non-judmentalism is kind of like pacifism. It gives the impression of withdrawal, of “not doing” anything. But when we are serious about not judging, we discover it is a very active process.
So this is what I learned from a Mennonite peacemaker, Buddhist meditation, and Lenten devotions.
I heard John Paul Lederach speak at Bethany Seminary when I was a student. Lederach is a Mennonite who currently teaches at Notre Dame, but, more notably, Lederach is a well respected practitioner of international conflict transformation. I was reminded of him and his work when he was featured on NPR’s “Speaking of Faith” a couple weeks ago. And I was struck by how his approach to conflict transformation is relevant to so many aspects of our lives, even helping us drop our stones of judgments.
It involves cultivating, within ourselves, what he calls a “moral imagination.”
According to Lederach, the moral imagination is the capacity to recognize and take advantage of turning points and possibilities present to us in order to venture down unknown paths that create something entirely new. But first and foremost it requires us to see ourselves as part of a web of relationships, one that even includes our enemies … and people or situations we consistently judge.
We need to recognize we are all connected, one organism based on mutuality. It urges us to suspend the polarities of our judgments—moving beyond seeing the world in black and white, recognizing that human situations are more complex than winners and losers, best ideas and worse ideas, right choices and wrong choices. If we can do this, the moral imagination replaces our judgment by showing us surprising opportunities for connection, and unexpected potential for relationships, even in the face of differences.
Isn’t it relationships over polarities that Jesus emphasizes? I think Jesus is exhibiting a bit of moral imagination in our scripture for today. He is recognizing a turning point, a moment of tension where things could go any which way, the possibility of a new outcome, a new reaction, a new heart. In the midst of attack and judgment … when Jesus was invited to judge, he saw a turning point and he simply stopped.
Perhaps that is a good starting point for us. In my studies of Buddhism and in my on again off again yoga practice, I’ve been introduced to a practice called mindfulness. It is, simply put, trying to be absolutely present in the moment. Not dwelling on the past, or anticipating the future. Perhaps practicing mindfulness can help us crouch with Jesus as he writes in the dirt.
So while we’re here, let’s stop ourselves and practice a little – a moment of mindfulness. Take a few moments to think about what, or whom you are very judgmental, or critical, about. Maybe it’s an individual, or a behavior. It might be a group, or a way of thinking, or a belief system. What is that judgment you have? [pause]
Now imagine you encounter that person, that group, or that behavior. And you feel that bubbling of judgment starting to heat up. It shoots from your brain down to your stomach where it ferments for a moment. Then it rises up your throat and comes out in critical or hurtful words.
The first step of applying mindfulness to our judgments starts here, where you recognize what is happening. You notice what is going on, especially the physical sensations. You might notice your chest getting tight, your lips pursing, your brow knitting. I notice I’m rolling my eyes or feel the beginning of a smirk. What is your body doing.?
Now describe what you’re seeing – put into words what is going on that might be causing that sensation. The person in the grocery line has food I don’t approve. The news story is talking about a politician I don’t like. My friend has made bad decisions. But that description is itself a judgment. Practice seeing the person over the problem. Be in the moment with what you are seeing, describing the person you see, not what they’re doing or saying…. I’m looking at the person in front of me in the checkout line. I am watching a news story. I am talking with a friend. Dwell with the image of the person
And if through practice we can get to the point where we see the person rather than the problem, we might be sewing that web together where we would otherwise be cutting it apart. Simply stopping that runaway train of immediate evaluation and snap judgment helps us to be less judgmental people.
Perhaps in some way this is what Jesus was doing. Jesus stopped and wrote in the dirt. We don’t know what he’s wrote, but the act of writing itself was important enough for the author of John to include it. It meant something. Something was happening. Maybe it wasn’t so much what he was writing but what the process of his writing did in the situation.
He confused the process, forced things to stop. He threw everyone off guard and got them to look at themselves instead of the adulteress. He stopped the violent cycle
Now maybe that still seems vague and complex. Maybe it would be more helpful to look at non-judmentalism as a spiritual discipline just like any other. You could apply the spiritual discipline of silence.
This is what Torin and I did last year during Lent when we found our tendency to be judgmental was spinning out of control. We simply practiced silence and stopped giving voice to your judgments. Even if you think them, don’t say them. It can seem simplistic or misguided, but we found that it helped. Often in our sharing our judgments with others (especially if they are not those people we are judging) we are really looking for someone to agree with us that we are better than the person we are judging. If I have the ear of someone else, my judgments become catty, even more hurtful, and I become more and more separated from that web of relationships.
Now, not speaking your judgments doesn’t mean you won’t have them, but like Jesus writing in the dirt, it stops that cycle for a moment—when we actively think that silence is needed, it brings it to our attention that we were about to say something judgmental. We can then look at the judgments mindfully. It allows us to ask questions of our judgments. We can ask ourselves, will this observation build up or tear down? Will I be more connected with the web of relationships, or leave me disconnected? Is this about making me feel superior?
Connectedness, mindfulness, prayer, and silence. That’s a tall order. But I believe it can be worth the work. Jesus gives us an example of mercy, but he also gives us, with stones in hand, a chance to also practice it. He didn’t just give the angry crowd words of non-judgment, he gave them an opportunity to participate in his gospel of mercy. When he says, “Go and sin no more,” it is hard to hear it as a command to the woman without hoping it will touch the ears of those walking away.
Our work at relinquishing judgment, is our living out Christ’s gospel. May the passion overcome the pain as we become bearers of Love.
Sunday, July 18, 2010
Jonah, Jesus, and Judgment: Part One
sermon by Carrie Eikler
John 8:2-11, Jonah 3&4
(*earlier in the service we lit our peace lamp for Sakineh Ashtiani, an Iranian woman who was charged in 2006 with adultery and sentenced to death by stoning. The UN, US and British governments, as well as many humanitarian organizations have appealed for a stay of execution, and for the time being, this week we heard her stoning has been put on hold. For Sakineh Ashtiani, we light this lamp for her safety, and for mercy on the part of the Iranian government. May they, and we, receive God’s merciful peace.)
"Jonah, Jesus, and Judgment: Part One"
When AJ Jacobs set out on a quest to live out the Bible literally for one full year, he had no idea what to expect. Jacobs is the editor at large of the magazine Esquire. He lives in New York, and was raised a secular Jew: as he puts it he is a Jew in the same way Olive Garden is an Italian Restaurant. Which is to say: not very. In his book, entitled The Year of Living Biblically: One Man’s Humble Quest to Follow the Bible as Literally as Possible he outlines his adventures of seeking the meaning of religion, while also attempting to satisfy some deep spiritual yearning of his own, by living out the Bible--literally. For one full year. Trying to obey the entire Bible without picking and choosing.
So that meant to obey the Ten Commandments. To be fruitful and multiply. To love his neighbor. To tithe his income. But also to abide by the often-neglected rules: To avoid wearing clothes made of mixed fibers. To leave the edges of his beard unshaven. To stone adulterers. Yes, to stone adulterers.
The scene that is presented before us in John, sadly, has biblical backing. Stoning an adulterer, like the one standing in front of Jesus, was a justifiable punishment. In many biblical respects, she had it coming. Yet, while the Bible gives grounds for such a punishment, we realize it doesn’t make it less abhorrent in our eyes.
When AJ Jacobs tackled capital punishment, number two on what he called Most Perplexing Laws [of the Bible], (right after the law of not wearing mixed fibers), he thought he found a loophole: it doesn’t say what size the stones should be. So he chose only tiny pebbles…
Imagine yourself witness to this scene…from Jacobs’ book:
I am resting in a small public park on the Upper West Side, the kind where you see retirees eating tuna sandwiches on benches.
“Hey, you’re dressed queer.”
I look over. The speaker is an elderly man, mid-70s I’d guess. He is tall and thin and is wearing one of those caps that cabbies wore in movies from the Forties.
“You’re dressed queer,” he snarls. “Why you dressed so queer.” [Now remember, he is trying to dress as prescribed in the Old Testament] I have on my usual fringes, and, for good measure, have worn some sandals and am carrying a knotty maple walking stick I’d bought on the Internet for $25.
“I’m trying to live by the rules of the Bible. The 10 commandments, stoning adulterers…”
“You’re stoning adulterers?”
“Yeah, I’m stoning adulterers.”
“I’m an adulterer.”
“You’re currently an adulterer?”
“Yeah. Tonight, tomorrow, yesterday, two weeks from now. You gonna stone me?”
“If I could, yes, that’d be great.”
“I’ll punch you in the face. I’ll send you to the cemetery.”
He is serious. This isn’t a cutesy grumpy old man. This is an angry old man. This is a man with seven decades of hostility behind him.
I fish out my pebbles from my back pocket.
“I wouldn’t stone you with big stones,” I say. “Just these little guys.”
I open my palm to show him the pebbles. He lunges at me, grabbing one out of my hand, then chucking it at my face. It whizzes by my cheek.
I am stunned for a second. I hadn’t expected this elderly man to make the first move. But now there is nothing stopping me from retaliating. An eye for an eye.
I take one of the remaining pebbles and whip it at his chest. It bounces off.
“I’ll punch you right in the kisser,” he says.
“Well, you really shouldn’t commit adultery,” I say.
We stare at each other. My heart is racing.
Yes, he is a septuagenarian. Yes, he had just threatened me using corny Honeymooners dialogue. But you could tell: This man has a strong dark side.
Our glaring contest lasts ten seconds, then he walks away, brushing by me as he leaves.
As critical as AJ Jacobs is of biblical capital punishment, he admitted that in that experience, he found some satisfaction in his light stoning. He said: It felt good to chuck a rock at this nasty old man. It felt primal. It felt like I was getting vengeance on him. This guy wasn’t just an adulterer, he was a bully. I wanted him to feel the pain he’d inflicted on others, even if that pain was a tap on the chest…
[But], he confessed, I also knew that this was a morally stunted way to feel.
*
When Jonah cried out a warning that the people of Ninevah would be overthrown, as directed by God, he likely wasn’t expecting them to listen. And more than that, he probably wasn’t expecting God to show mercy. Jonah perches himself high on a hill, looking down on the blasphemers and evildoers-waiting for a show of God’s wrath, waiting to see what would become of the city.
When the crowd cornered an adulteress in front of the popular rabbi, Jesus, they likely weren’t expecting him to ask them about their sin. And more than that, they probably weren’t expecting Jesus to do what he did: to crouch down and show mercy. They had perched themselves symbolically above, scowling down on the sexually deviant woman, waiting for a word of condemnation, waiting to see what would become of this woman…adulteress…sinner.
When I told my friend this weekend that I was preaching on judgment, he raised his eyebrows and said, “Really? My wife should go and listen to that.” Scriptures like these are what I like to call “yeah-those” stories. I call them that because my initial reaction when I hear them is to say “Yeah-those people who really need to hear this story should listen to what it has to say to them.” If those people would just hear these “yeah-those” scriptures they could sort themselves out.
But what I have come to find is that the more vehemently I latch onto a “yeah-those” scripture or story for what I think it has to say to others, the more I have found it is really an “Oh-I” story. “Oh. I guess this says more about me, than about them.” “Oh. I think the one who really needs to listen is myself.” And in the case of today’s stories, “Oh. I guess these stories about judgment could be less about others shaping up first and more about my delight in judging.”
Why do you think we judge? No, I really am asking a serious question because I would love to know, so I could fix myself, at least. It would make sense if there was some logical biological reason behind it. Like judging other people aids us in our survival of a species, or something like that.
Granted, we know that there is definitely a place for judgment—we like to call it discernment, or reasoning, or assessment. It is essential in making good choices: How do I feel about this book I just read. Would I want to make that mistake again? Do I take this job, marry this person? Should I eat this piece of rotten smelling meat? Judgment is important in our day to day living.
But obviously, this is not what Jesus is talking about, or what Jonah is experiencing. They are shining light on the personal. The interior condemnation we have of other people. The joy we get in passing judgment on others.
I do think however, from my own struggle with judgmentalism, that judgments come from a place within us that is simultaneously passionate, and yet painful. Next week I hope we can explore the hopeful transformation of our passion beyond our judgments, but before we get there, we probably need to poke at the pain.
*
I see two major types of judgers. And yes, I am in the mix. I see these both in myself. Consider this part of my confession.
First are the judging zealots. I am the stoning type. I am not afraid to get in your face, or at least send you a nasty email or get a radio talk show, and say just what it is that you are doing wrong. Or, as really is the case with me, I want to have conversation after conversation with you about my views, whether you invite me to or not…because I don’t think you’ve quite heard me yet. If you would do what I say, or see it my way, you would have it figured out and somehow you will be saved.
And I think salvation is a big part of being a judging zealot. All I want to do is save you from something: maybe it’s salvation from hell or sin, maybe I want to save you from your lifestyle choices of food or drink or stress, I want to save you from the a sexually deviant lifestyle. I want to save you from the destruction of your intolerance. I want to simply save you from your own ignorance.
As a zealot, I’m in the minority, but I’m really loud. Yeah, I might turn you off, but it’s only because I have the truth and you can’t. handle. the. truth.
But usually, I am like most people, who aren’t those zealous judgers. I’m not terribly loud, and god-forbid, I don’t judge. I’m not throwing stones or proclaiming God’s wrath. I simply stew in criticism of other people. Not only individuals, but groups of people. Those with a label, or a behavior I don’t like. Or different ideas. It’s an easier way of being a judger because I really don’t have to go out of my house or engage anybody at all. I simply have to think I’m more knowledgeable, more experienced, more superior in power or intellect …closer to knowing what God wants.
Oh, and I’ll let you in on a little secret. It’s much easier to be a critic if you absolutely do not surround yourself by anyone who thinks differently than you do. A little bit is ok, but dramatically different. Nope. don’t do it
As a criticizer I’d really love those people to be saved from their wayward thoughts, but I’ll just continue to think how wrong they are, and feel better about myself. Quietly criticizing….
**
The book of Jonah is a strange, short story. If he is not surviving in the belly of a big fish, he is proclaiming judgment on Ninevah and then sulking when God decides to show mercy. And it’s that last bit that we zealots and critics can really relate to (unless any of you have been swallowed by a big fish). And when we look at the pouting Jonah through our own experiences, we understand what he is doing.
When I judge--and yes I do believe that uninvited criticism of others (to their face or in the safety of your own solitude) is judgment—when I judge or criticize I am not wanting to “save” anything. Not really. Not Ninevah. Not people who don’t “get it.”
Quicker than it takes God to move from wrath to mercy, we realize that our judgment never brings salvation to others. It doesn’t even bring it to ourselves.
No, I don’t want to save anybody. I simply want to feel superior. I want to set myself apart and above. To look down on the once-heathens. To look down on the current-sinner. To look down on those who just don’t get it like I do.
Why else would Jonah not rejoice Ninevah’s repentance? Why else would he say he would rather die than witness God’s mercy on these heathens?
Jonah reflects the self-destructive powers of our own judgments. Instead of the salvation we may be convinced of, it brings division that is hard to see, but easily felt.
**
When the woman who was caught in adultery was forced before Jesus, he didn’t look down on her. Rather, he lowered himself to the ground…and wrote in the dirt—all eyes down…on him. We don’t know what he writes, but we know it is a moment of tension. What will he do? What will he say? Is he pondering the question, or does he already know the answer? Will he do what we know the law says?
And to me this is a pivotal moment in the slow unfolding of Christ’s gospel.
Don’t think you are any better than she.
When we judge and criticize others for who they are, what they believe, how they live, it is never about them. As AJ Jacobs discovered, even a small pebble bouncing off the chest of a big bully has ramifications for ourselves. Our criticizing judgments are about our own fear that somehow this world is made up of those better than and those less than. And we want to be on top. Superior. Looking down on others.
Today, we hold pebbles in our hands. There is no doubt we are judgers: zealots and critics. How do your judgments or criticisms have a hold on you? Do you build yourself up by tearing others down, if only in your mind? What is this stone you are holding and who are you holding it against?
**
We want the tiny pebbles in our hand to fling at will. Do we really see life as a zero-sum game—that there is no room in our world for people who are different from us? Do I really think that the world should be just like me. Or if not like me, then at least how I wish I could be. Do I really think that when the world is made in my own image, things would be perfect.
If that is how we really feel, then yes, we are more like Jonah than we think.
If this is how we really feel--what a painful life we live.
But Christ, bending down in the dirt, writes something different for us…
John 8:2-11, Jonah 3&4
(*earlier in the service we lit our peace lamp for Sakineh Ashtiani, an Iranian woman who was charged in 2006 with adultery and sentenced to death by stoning. The UN, US and British governments, as well as many humanitarian organizations have appealed for a stay of execution, and for the time being, this week we heard her stoning has been put on hold. For Sakineh Ashtiani, we light this lamp for her safety, and for mercy on the part of the Iranian government. May they, and we, receive God’s merciful peace.)
"Jonah, Jesus, and Judgment: Part One"
When AJ Jacobs set out on a quest to live out the Bible literally for one full year, he had no idea what to expect. Jacobs is the editor at large of the magazine Esquire. He lives in New York, and was raised a secular Jew: as he puts it he is a Jew in the same way Olive Garden is an Italian Restaurant. Which is to say: not very. In his book, entitled The Year of Living Biblically: One Man’s Humble Quest to Follow the Bible as Literally as Possible he outlines his adventures of seeking the meaning of religion, while also attempting to satisfy some deep spiritual yearning of his own, by living out the Bible--literally. For one full year. Trying to obey the entire Bible without picking and choosing.
So that meant to obey the Ten Commandments. To be fruitful and multiply. To love his neighbor. To tithe his income. But also to abide by the often-neglected rules: To avoid wearing clothes made of mixed fibers. To leave the edges of his beard unshaven. To stone adulterers. Yes, to stone adulterers.
The scene that is presented before us in John, sadly, has biblical backing. Stoning an adulterer, like the one standing in front of Jesus, was a justifiable punishment. In many biblical respects, she had it coming. Yet, while the Bible gives grounds for such a punishment, we realize it doesn’t make it less abhorrent in our eyes.
When AJ Jacobs tackled capital punishment, number two on what he called Most Perplexing Laws [of the Bible], (right after the law of not wearing mixed fibers), he thought he found a loophole: it doesn’t say what size the stones should be. So he chose only tiny pebbles…
Imagine yourself witness to this scene…from Jacobs’ book:
I am resting in a small public park on the Upper West Side, the kind where you see retirees eating tuna sandwiches on benches.
“Hey, you’re dressed queer.”
I look over. The speaker is an elderly man, mid-70s I’d guess. He is tall and thin and is wearing one of those caps that cabbies wore in movies from the Forties.
“You’re dressed queer,” he snarls. “Why you dressed so queer.” [Now remember, he is trying to dress as prescribed in the Old Testament] I have on my usual fringes, and, for good measure, have worn some sandals and am carrying a knotty maple walking stick I’d bought on the Internet for $25.
“I’m trying to live by the rules of the Bible. The 10 commandments, stoning adulterers…”
“You’re stoning adulterers?”
“Yeah, I’m stoning adulterers.”
“I’m an adulterer.”
“You’re currently an adulterer?”
“Yeah. Tonight, tomorrow, yesterday, two weeks from now. You gonna stone me?”
“If I could, yes, that’d be great.”
“I’ll punch you in the face. I’ll send you to the cemetery.”
He is serious. This isn’t a cutesy grumpy old man. This is an angry old man. This is a man with seven decades of hostility behind him.
I fish out my pebbles from my back pocket.
“I wouldn’t stone you with big stones,” I say. “Just these little guys.”
I open my palm to show him the pebbles. He lunges at me, grabbing one out of my hand, then chucking it at my face. It whizzes by my cheek.
I am stunned for a second. I hadn’t expected this elderly man to make the first move. But now there is nothing stopping me from retaliating. An eye for an eye.
I take one of the remaining pebbles and whip it at his chest. It bounces off.
“I’ll punch you right in the kisser,” he says.
“Well, you really shouldn’t commit adultery,” I say.
We stare at each other. My heart is racing.
Yes, he is a septuagenarian. Yes, he had just threatened me using corny Honeymooners dialogue. But you could tell: This man has a strong dark side.
Our glaring contest lasts ten seconds, then he walks away, brushing by me as he leaves.
As critical as AJ Jacobs is of biblical capital punishment, he admitted that in that experience, he found some satisfaction in his light stoning. He said: It felt good to chuck a rock at this nasty old man. It felt primal. It felt like I was getting vengeance on him. This guy wasn’t just an adulterer, he was a bully. I wanted him to feel the pain he’d inflicted on others, even if that pain was a tap on the chest…
[But], he confessed, I also knew that this was a morally stunted way to feel.
*
When Jonah cried out a warning that the people of Ninevah would be overthrown, as directed by God, he likely wasn’t expecting them to listen. And more than that, he probably wasn’t expecting God to show mercy. Jonah perches himself high on a hill, looking down on the blasphemers and evildoers-waiting for a show of God’s wrath, waiting to see what would become of the city.
When the crowd cornered an adulteress in front of the popular rabbi, Jesus, they likely weren’t expecting him to ask them about their sin. And more than that, they probably weren’t expecting Jesus to do what he did: to crouch down and show mercy. They had perched themselves symbolically above, scowling down on the sexually deviant woman, waiting for a word of condemnation, waiting to see what would become of this woman…adulteress…sinner.
When I told my friend this weekend that I was preaching on judgment, he raised his eyebrows and said, “Really? My wife should go and listen to that.” Scriptures like these are what I like to call “yeah-those” stories. I call them that because my initial reaction when I hear them is to say “Yeah-those people who really need to hear this story should listen to what it has to say to them.” If those people would just hear these “yeah-those” scriptures they could sort themselves out.
But what I have come to find is that the more vehemently I latch onto a “yeah-those” scripture or story for what I think it has to say to others, the more I have found it is really an “Oh-I” story. “Oh. I guess this says more about me, than about them.” “Oh. I think the one who really needs to listen is myself.” And in the case of today’s stories, “Oh. I guess these stories about judgment could be less about others shaping up first and more about my delight in judging.”
Why do you think we judge? No, I really am asking a serious question because I would love to know, so I could fix myself, at least. It would make sense if there was some logical biological reason behind it. Like judging other people aids us in our survival of a species, or something like that.
Granted, we know that there is definitely a place for judgment—we like to call it discernment, or reasoning, or assessment. It is essential in making good choices: How do I feel about this book I just read. Would I want to make that mistake again? Do I take this job, marry this person? Should I eat this piece of rotten smelling meat? Judgment is important in our day to day living.
But obviously, this is not what Jesus is talking about, or what Jonah is experiencing. They are shining light on the personal. The interior condemnation we have of other people. The joy we get in passing judgment on others.
I do think however, from my own struggle with judgmentalism, that judgments come from a place within us that is simultaneously passionate, and yet painful. Next week I hope we can explore the hopeful transformation of our passion beyond our judgments, but before we get there, we probably need to poke at the pain.
*
I see two major types of judgers. And yes, I am in the mix. I see these both in myself. Consider this part of my confession.
First are the judging zealots. I am the stoning type. I am not afraid to get in your face, or at least send you a nasty email or get a radio talk show, and say just what it is that you are doing wrong. Or, as really is the case with me, I want to have conversation after conversation with you about my views, whether you invite me to or not…because I don’t think you’ve quite heard me yet. If you would do what I say, or see it my way, you would have it figured out and somehow you will be saved.
And I think salvation is a big part of being a judging zealot. All I want to do is save you from something: maybe it’s salvation from hell or sin, maybe I want to save you from your lifestyle choices of food or drink or stress, I want to save you from the a sexually deviant lifestyle. I want to save you from the destruction of your intolerance. I want to simply save you from your own ignorance.
As a zealot, I’m in the minority, but I’m really loud. Yeah, I might turn you off, but it’s only because I have the truth and you can’t. handle. the. truth.
But usually, I am like most people, who aren’t those zealous judgers. I’m not terribly loud, and god-forbid, I don’t judge. I’m not throwing stones or proclaiming God’s wrath. I simply stew in criticism of other people. Not only individuals, but groups of people. Those with a label, or a behavior I don’t like. Or different ideas. It’s an easier way of being a judger because I really don’t have to go out of my house or engage anybody at all. I simply have to think I’m more knowledgeable, more experienced, more superior in power or intellect …closer to knowing what God wants.
Oh, and I’ll let you in on a little secret. It’s much easier to be a critic if you absolutely do not surround yourself by anyone who thinks differently than you do. A little bit is ok, but dramatically different. Nope. don’t do it
As a criticizer I’d really love those people to be saved from their wayward thoughts, but I’ll just continue to think how wrong they are, and feel better about myself. Quietly criticizing….
**
The book of Jonah is a strange, short story. If he is not surviving in the belly of a big fish, he is proclaiming judgment on Ninevah and then sulking when God decides to show mercy. And it’s that last bit that we zealots and critics can really relate to (unless any of you have been swallowed by a big fish). And when we look at the pouting Jonah through our own experiences, we understand what he is doing.
When I judge--and yes I do believe that uninvited criticism of others (to their face or in the safety of your own solitude) is judgment—when I judge or criticize I am not wanting to “save” anything. Not really. Not Ninevah. Not people who don’t “get it.”
Quicker than it takes God to move from wrath to mercy, we realize that our judgment never brings salvation to others. It doesn’t even bring it to ourselves.
No, I don’t want to save anybody. I simply want to feel superior. I want to set myself apart and above. To look down on the once-heathens. To look down on the current-sinner. To look down on those who just don’t get it like I do.
Why else would Jonah not rejoice Ninevah’s repentance? Why else would he say he would rather die than witness God’s mercy on these heathens?
Jonah reflects the self-destructive powers of our own judgments. Instead of the salvation we may be convinced of, it brings division that is hard to see, but easily felt.
**
When the woman who was caught in adultery was forced before Jesus, he didn’t look down on her. Rather, he lowered himself to the ground…and wrote in the dirt—all eyes down…on him. We don’t know what he writes, but we know it is a moment of tension. What will he do? What will he say? Is he pondering the question, or does he already know the answer? Will he do what we know the law says?
And to me this is a pivotal moment in the slow unfolding of Christ’s gospel.
Don’t think you are any better than she.
When we judge and criticize others for who they are, what they believe, how they live, it is never about them. As AJ Jacobs discovered, even a small pebble bouncing off the chest of a big bully has ramifications for ourselves. Our criticizing judgments are about our own fear that somehow this world is made up of those better than and those less than. And we want to be on top. Superior. Looking down on others.
Today, we hold pebbles in our hands. There is no doubt we are judgers: zealots and critics. How do your judgments or criticisms have a hold on you? Do you build yourself up by tearing others down, if only in your mind? What is this stone you are holding and who are you holding it against?
**
We want the tiny pebbles in our hand to fling at will. Do we really see life as a zero-sum game—that there is no room in our world for people who are different from us? Do I really think that the world should be just like me. Or if not like me, then at least how I wish I could be. Do I really think that when the world is made in my own image, things would be perfect.
If that is how we really feel, then yes, we are more like Jonah than we think.
If this is how we really feel--what a painful life we live.
But Christ, bending down in the dirt, writes something different for us…
Sunday, June 27, 2010
The God of Elijah
sermon by Torin Eikler
I Kings 17:1-23,19:1-19
Fourth in series: "God's People in the Hebrew Scriptures"
Though the prophet Elijah does not have a book of his own, he is unquestionably one of the most entertaining prophets in the Hebrew Scriptures that make up our Old Testament. His story is told in the books of the Kings that chronicle the time between the division of Israel into a northern and a southern kingdom in 922 BC … and 587 BC when the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem marked the end to the “golden age” of the chosen people. Elijah, himself, lived and right in the middle of that period and prophesied to three of the kings who turned the northern kingdom to the worship of the Canaanite god, Baal. In the course of the six chapters in which he appears, he experiences and accomplishes more than most of our other characters do in their whole lives.
He predicted a drought and its ending as well as the death of two kings. He carried out a duel in divine power with 500 priests of Baal and had all of them put to death upon his victory. And, he delivered general critiques on the apostasy of the nation.
As a result, he had to flee to the wilderness at least three times: once to the wilderness where he was fed by ravens and then guided to the door of a poor widow where he performs a resurrection; once to the desert where he was fed by the hands of angels before trekking forty days and nights to a cave on Mount Horeb where he encountered God in the “sound of fine silence;” and once to the hill country where he brought down fire to consume fifty hapless soldiers and their commander … twice before going to condemn king Ahaziah to death.
Finally, Elijah goes on a whirlwind tour of Israel with his successor, Elisha, and I mean that literally. The two of them were actually carted around the country by whirlwinds before landing on the banks of the Jordan. There he parted the waters with a touch of his cloak, and while the two men were walking along on the other side, a chariot of fire came and carried him into heaven.
Quite a busy guy! … But such was the life of only prophet of the true God to survive Jezebel’s rule as Queen.
Of all his adventures, the text that Jacob sang for us today is probably the one most often heard in sermons. It is the part of the story where Elijah runs to the desert to escape Queen Jezebel’s wrath after destroying her royal priests. There he laments the hardships of his life and pleads with God to let him die. In response, he is given Angel food … cakes of bread and jars of water to strengthen him for the journey to the mountain of the Lord. There he hides in a cave through a stone-splitting wind, a bone-rattling earthquake, and blood-boiling fire until the sound of fine silence coaxes him out to speak with the still, small voice of the Lord.
I imagine the whole experience was quite harrowing for the prophet. Such a hot, dry trek through the rough land of the wilderness that lasted as long as the flood could not have been easy. Throw in all the dangers of wild animals, the trauma of hunger, and the incredible sense of alone-ness, and I suspect Elijah was regretting his request for death or at least wishing that it would have been granted in a much easier fashion. And given his attitude – both at the beginning of the story and in the way he speaks to God on the mountain – one would expect a divine rebuke to come along at any moment. Instead, God accepts him as he is – anger, depression, passion, faith, and fear all rolled up together – and meets him there in his wilderness.
Jesus said, “Ask, and it will be given you; seek, and you will find; knock, and the door will opened to you,” and I know of many people who have experienced this to be true. In times of dire need or even in the midst of everyday life, they have asked for help from God and received exactly what they needed: angels appearing to help change a tire or the chance appearance of a stream of water in front of someone lost in the desert or a miraculous recovery from terminal disease. Elijah doesn’t even ask. He doesn’t knock. And he certainly doesn’t seek. If anything, he closes his eyes for fear that he might find. Yet he receives what he most needed: food to eat, angelic company to encourage him, and the promise of a partner to help him in his work.
In my own experience (and that of many others) thing don’t work quite that way. I’ll admit that I don’t often resort to asking God for help. I tend to trust to my own efforts or find my own way out a mess instead. Yet in the times when I have been at the end of my rope and turned to God, I have never heard the voice of an angel or felt the hand of God reach out to support or save me.
Despite what many people say, I don’t think that shows a lack of faith on my part. Nor does it imply that God is fickle or doesn’t really care most of the time. In fact, I think it’s exactly the opposite because the other side of my story is that each time I that I asked (and many, many times when I didn’t) I did receive. Friends have shown up to help me out of my depression. Travelers have stopped to offer me a ride and gone out of their way a half hour or more to get me home. Strangers opened their door to me in the middle of a "blizzardy" winter’s night while I waited for the wrecker to come and tow my car. And, in the midst of the most dangerous situations in my life, there has been a feeling of calm and peace that has settled over me, reminding me that God is with me always.
What does that mean? How do I … how do any of make sense of experiences like those? I don’t know. I don’t know if we can make “sense” out of them because in a very real way, God resists our attempts to limit the way we experience her presence. God came to Elijah in the parching hunger of drought, in the purging fire of righteousness, in the upending power of the whirlwind, and in calm sound of fine silence. God comes to me in a sense of quiet stillness. And God, I believe, comes to all of us in the hands and hearts of those around us.
There is a joke about a devout man who was caught in a flood. He climbed to the roof of his house to escape the rising water and began to pray to God to save him. The water continued to rise, and some short time later a neighbor came by in his fishing boat. He stopped and called to the man on the roof to come down so that he could ferry him to safety, but the man refused, saying, “The Lord will save me.”
Some hours later, the water had begun to pour through the windows on the second story, and the man once again prayed to God for salvation. Soon, a small ship found its way to the house, and the people on board tossed a rope onto the roof so that the man could climb on board. The man calmly got up and threw the rope back to them, saying, “My God will save me.”
When the water had reached halfway up the roof and was just ten feet below the man’s feet, he knelt on the peak with his head bowed low, beseeching God to rescue him from certain death until the sound of an approaching helicopter caught his attention. The rescue crew lowered a ladder to the roof and shouted for him to climb up, but the man waved them away, shouting that his faith would save him. Shaking their heads in disbelief, the crew relayed the message to the pilot, and they flew off in search of others in need of help.
Eventually, the water swept the man away to his doom, and he found himself standing before God with just one question burning in his mind. “Lord,” he said, “I prayed to you for help three times. Why didn’t do anything.”
God replied, “What do you mean. I sent you two boats and a helicopter.”
In my life, God has chosen to work through others rather than through miraculous manifestations of divine power. My guess is that has been true for most of you, too. It was also the experience of the early Anabaptists. As they sought relief from persecution and the threat of death, they found the homes of others – Anabaptist or not – open to them. There are stories of soldiers and community leaders who turned a blind eye to their presence or even gave them help when asked though doing so could mean death or imprisonment for them. These experiences, together with their understanding of Jesus’ teachings led them to value the practice of caring for one another as a central part of the discipleship of the faith community. They came to rely on each other and trust that they would receive the care of the God who was always with them even if it was through the hands of strangers.
Elijah experienced that reality too. When he first found himself in the wilderness fearing for his life, the ravens fed him, but he didn’t remain there. He was sent back to civilization when his stream dried up to seek the help of an unknown widow in the town of Zarephath. The widow and her son took him in. They fed him the last of their food only to find that her stock of flour and oil was continually replenished for three years until the drought ended. And in the end, Elijah cared for the widow in return, giving her back her son who would provide for her in the time to come.
What the story of Elijah’s life illustrates … what the early Anabaptists understood … and what we recognize in our own experience when we pay attention is that God is there for us. God surrounds and supports us wherever and whenever we find ourselves in need. It may not come in the way we expect it to or even in a way that we really want it to. It may come in the form of a minor or major miracle. More often it comes at the hand of a brother or sister or friend or stranger who reaches out to us with compassion and, by their actions, invites us to reach out to others in turn
I think that’s the way God works … by bringing people together to love and care for one another. I think God knows that that is the way to heal the brokenness within and between us … to bring reconciliation and renewal to all of humanity. I think that’s why God came to us as Jesus … to show us how powerful that kind of love can be and to invite us to follow his example … to become God’s people with hearts full of compassion and lives embodying loving care for all God’s children.
I Kings 17:1-23,19:1-19
Fourth in series: "God's People in the Hebrew Scriptures"
Though the prophet Elijah does not have a book of his own, he is unquestionably one of the most entertaining prophets in the Hebrew Scriptures that make up our Old Testament. His story is told in the books of the Kings that chronicle the time between the division of Israel into a northern and a southern kingdom in 922 BC … and 587 BC when the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem marked the end to the “golden age” of the chosen people. Elijah, himself, lived and right in the middle of that period and prophesied to three of the kings who turned the northern kingdom to the worship of the Canaanite god, Baal. In the course of the six chapters in which he appears, he experiences and accomplishes more than most of our other characters do in their whole lives.
He predicted a drought and its ending as well as the death of two kings. He carried out a duel in divine power with 500 priests of Baal and had all of them put to death upon his victory. And, he delivered general critiques on the apostasy of the nation.
As a result, he had to flee to the wilderness at least three times: once to the wilderness where he was fed by ravens and then guided to the door of a poor widow where he performs a resurrection; once to the desert where he was fed by the hands of angels before trekking forty days and nights to a cave on Mount Horeb where he encountered God in the “sound of fine silence;” and once to the hill country where he brought down fire to consume fifty hapless soldiers and their commander … twice before going to condemn king Ahaziah to death.
Finally, Elijah goes on a whirlwind tour of Israel with his successor, Elisha, and I mean that literally. The two of them were actually carted around the country by whirlwinds before landing on the banks of the Jordan. There he parted the waters with a touch of his cloak, and while the two men were walking along on the other side, a chariot of fire came and carried him into heaven.
Quite a busy guy! … But such was the life of only prophet of the true God to survive Jezebel’s rule as Queen.
Of all his adventures, the text that Jacob sang for us today is probably the one most often heard in sermons. It is the part of the story where Elijah runs to the desert to escape Queen Jezebel’s wrath after destroying her royal priests. There he laments the hardships of his life and pleads with God to let him die. In response, he is given Angel food … cakes of bread and jars of water to strengthen him for the journey to the mountain of the Lord. There he hides in a cave through a stone-splitting wind, a bone-rattling earthquake, and blood-boiling fire until the sound of fine silence coaxes him out to speak with the still, small voice of the Lord.
I imagine the whole experience was quite harrowing for the prophet. Such a hot, dry trek through the rough land of the wilderness that lasted as long as the flood could not have been easy. Throw in all the dangers of wild animals, the trauma of hunger, and the incredible sense of alone-ness, and I suspect Elijah was regretting his request for death or at least wishing that it would have been granted in a much easier fashion. And given his attitude – both at the beginning of the story and in the way he speaks to God on the mountain – one would expect a divine rebuke to come along at any moment. Instead, God accepts him as he is – anger, depression, passion, faith, and fear all rolled up together – and meets him there in his wilderness.
Jesus said, “Ask, and it will be given you; seek, and you will find; knock, and the door will opened to you,” and I know of many people who have experienced this to be true. In times of dire need or even in the midst of everyday life, they have asked for help from God and received exactly what they needed: angels appearing to help change a tire or the chance appearance of a stream of water in front of someone lost in the desert or a miraculous recovery from terminal disease. Elijah doesn’t even ask. He doesn’t knock. And he certainly doesn’t seek. If anything, he closes his eyes for fear that he might find. Yet he receives what he most needed: food to eat, angelic company to encourage him, and the promise of a partner to help him in his work.
In my own experience (and that of many others) thing don’t work quite that way. I’ll admit that I don’t often resort to asking God for help. I tend to trust to my own efforts or find my own way out a mess instead. Yet in the times when I have been at the end of my rope and turned to God, I have never heard the voice of an angel or felt the hand of God reach out to support or save me.
Despite what many people say, I don’t think that shows a lack of faith on my part. Nor does it imply that God is fickle or doesn’t really care most of the time. In fact, I think it’s exactly the opposite because the other side of my story is that each time I that I asked (and many, many times when I didn’t) I did receive. Friends have shown up to help me out of my depression. Travelers have stopped to offer me a ride and gone out of their way a half hour or more to get me home. Strangers opened their door to me in the middle of a "blizzardy" winter’s night while I waited for the wrecker to come and tow my car. And, in the midst of the most dangerous situations in my life, there has been a feeling of calm and peace that has settled over me, reminding me that God is with me always.
What does that mean? How do I … how do any of make sense of experiences like those? I don’t know. I don’t know if we can make “sense” out of them because in a very real way, God resists our attempts to limit the way we experience her presence. God came to Elijah in the parching hunger of drought, in the purging fire of righteousness, in the upending power of the whirlwind, and in calm sound of fine silence. God comes to me in a sense of quiet stillness. And God, I believe, comes to all of us in the hands and hearts of those around us.
There is a joke about a devout man who was caught in a flood. He climbed to the roof of his house to escape the rising water and began to pray to God to save him. The water continued to rise, and some short time later a neighbor came by in his fishing boat. He stopped and called to the man on the roof to come down so that he could ferry him to safety, but the man refused, saying, “The Lord will save me.”
Some hours later, the water had begun to pour through the windows on the second story, and the man once again prayed to God for salvation. Soon, a small ship found its way to the house, and the people on board tossed a rope onto the roof so that the man could climb on board. The man calmly got up and threw the rope back to them, saying, “My God will save me.”
When the water had reached halfway up the roof and was just ten feet below the man’s feet, he knelt on the peak with his head bowed low, beseeching God to rescue him from certain death until the sound of an approaching helicopter caught his attention. The rescue crew lowered a ladder to the roof and shouted for him to climb up, but the man waved them away, shouting that his faith would save him. Shaking their heads in disbelief, the crew relayed the message to the pilot, and they flew off in search of others in need of help.
Eventually, the water swept the man away to his doom, and he found himself standing before God with just one question burning in his mind. “Lord,” he said, “I prayed to you for help three times. Why didn’t do anything.”
God replied, “What do you mean. I sent you two boats and a helicopter.”
In my life, God has chosen to work through others rather than through miraculous manifestations of divine power. My guess is that has been true for most of you, too. It was also the experience of the early Anabaptists. As they sought relief from persecution and the threat of death, they found the homes of others – Anabaptist or not – open to them. There are stories of soldiers and community leaders who turned a blind eye to their presence or even gave them help when asked though doing so could mean death or imprisonment for them. These experiences, together with their understanding of Jesus’ teachings led them to value the practice of caring for one another as a central part of the discipleship of the faith community. They came to rely on each other and trust that they would receive the care of the God who was always with them even if it was through the hands of strangers.
Elijah experienced that reality too. When he first found himself in the wilderness fearing for his life, the ravens fed him, but he didn’t remain there. He was sent back to civilization when his stream dried up to seek the help of an unknown widow in the town of Zarephath. The widow and her son took him in. They fed him the last of their food only to find that her stock of flour and oil was continually replenished for three years until the drought ended. And in the end, Elijah cared for the widow in return, giving her back her son who would provide for her in the time to come.
What the story of Elijah’s life illustrates … what the early Anabaptists understood … and what we recognize in our own experience when we pay attention is that God is there for us. God surrounds and supports us wherever and whenever we find ourselves in need. It may not come in the way we expect it to or even in a way that we really want it to. It may come in the form of a minor or major miracle. More often it comes at the hand of a brother or sister or friend or stranger who reaches out to us with compassion and, by their actions, invites us to reach out to others in turn
I think that’s the way God works … by bringing people together to love and care for one another. I think God knows that that is the way to heal the brokenness within and between us … to bring reconciliation and renewal to all of humanity. I think that’s why God came to us as Jesus … to show us how powerful that kind of love can be and to invite us to follow his example … to become God’s people with hearts full of compassion and lives embodying loving care for all God’s children.
Sunday, June 20, 2010
On Love and Loyalty
sermon by Torin Eikler
Ruth 1-2:13
Third in series: "God's People in the Hebrew Scriptures"
Today we continue our series with the Book of Ruth which is strangely appropriate given the current controversy over immigration policy. Though we call the book Ruth, it is as much the story of her mother-in-law, Naomi, as it is hers, and it is full of irony that we miss if we don’t know Hebrew.
Naomi, whose name means sweet, sets out from Bethlehem, the “house of bread,” with her husband because there is a famine in the land. They immigrate to Moab for relief even though Moabites were universally held in contempt by Israelites. There they settle, and their two sons marry Moabite women who Naomi loves as daughters. Eventually, all three men die, leaving Naomi, Orpah, and Ruth widowed and destitute, and Naomi, no longer sweet but embittered, decides to return to her ancestral home because just as bread has finally returned to Bethlehem.
On a deeper level, this story is set in opposition to the book of Judges. As we have heard from the previous two stories in our series, the time of the judges was not Israel at its best. Though the era started out fairly well, the Israelites began to turn away from God, and by the end, as Carrie pointed out, “all the people did what was right in their own eyes.” They lived selfishly and ignored the needs of those around them rather than following the Law that had held them together as a people. Over time that lack of loyalty and kindness led to division and death.
In contrast, Ruth chooses the way of kindness and loyalty. She leaves behind her home, her family, and her country to follow Naomi. She leaves behind a certain amount of security and a future with some hope for a “normal” life. She sets out into an uncertain future in a country where she is sure to be despised for the sake of love, and her faithful love reaches beyond the obligations and requirements of duty to bring a scattered family together in the promise of new life.
Jesus told his disciples, once, that following him might well mean leaving behind mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, and all the comfort and familiarity of home to make just such a trip into the unknown. Of all the instructions that he gave his followers, that has always seemed the most difficult to understand.
“Sell all you have and give it to the poor.” That’s a hard one, and I haven’t heard of anyone actually doing it – even the disciples. Still, it makes sense.
“If anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn the other also.” Even apart from certain interpretations of this as an act of resistance to the Roman Empire, I can get behind this one. I can even put it into practice from time to time.
But … “I have come to set a man against his father and a daughter against her mother …. And everyone who has left houses or brothers or sisters or father or mother or children for my name’s sake, … will inherit eternal life.” That’s one that gives me pause.
I remember when I was preparing for my baptism about a year after Carrie and I were married. That scripture came around in the lectionary cycle, and it hit me hard. I have no recollection at all of the rest of worship that day. I was stuck, wrestling with the thought that God might require me to leave my family behind. That’s not how I understood God, but it seemed to be a hard fact … right there … staring me in the face.
A few days later, I broached the topic with Carrie and shared my fears that my vows to God might, one day, have to take precedence over my vows to her. To her credit, she responded calmly and compassionately. We talked for awhile, and she reminded me that Jesus’ words were spoken to people who might have to leave their family if they chose to become disciples of Christ not to families who were already committed to that path. She also agreed with my belief that God would not choose to pull families apart … at least most of the time. So, I continued down the path to my dunking with only a manageable amount of anxiety.
Yet, what I shied away from as a possible duty of discipleship (well … ran away kicking and screaming might be a better description), Ruth embraced wholeheartedly. She left behind everything – even her gods – not because she had to, but because of her love. Having known Naomi for 10 years while she was true to her name – that is pleasant and sweet, she stays with her even when the turns of life have twisted her heart, turning her into Mara - bitter and resentful. Perhaps she was motivated by compassion. Perhaps it was something else. Whatever the reason, she models the steadfast love of God and becomes a stranger in a strange land.
Now, the Israelites were not known for treating Moabites - or any other foreigners – very well, especially during the time of the judges. And Naomi didn’t do very much to make the situation any better. She didn’t introduce her to the women of Bethlehem … didn’t explain the situation … didn’t even acknowledge her presence there beside her, turned in on herself as she was. But it seems that things weren’t too bad for Ruth.
She was confident enough in her safety to go out gleaning – to follow along behind the harvesters and pick up any little bits of barley that had fallen to the ground. Gleaning was a sacred right preserved in the Law of Moses as one of the few ways for widows and orphans to sustain themselves, but it was hot and tedious work without any protection from the sun or, apparently, the unwanted attention of the harvesters. So, it was particularly fortunately that Ruth found herself in fields that belonged to Naomi’s cousin, Boaz, who chooses to honor Ruth’s steadfastness with a blessing where others would have ignored and mistreated her as an unwanted immigrant.
When I was in sixteen or seventeen, a boy named Ricardo attended high school with us for a couple of years. He was Guatemalan by birth though he had spent much of his life living in the United States. His parents crossed the border in the 70s trying to escape the harsh realities of civil war. They hoped to find good work and make a better life for Ricardo and his brother and sister, and they were able to do pretty well for awhile.
That was before public sentiment began to turn so strongly against illegal immigrants in the 80s.
When that happened, the hostility of the people around them and increased pressure made life hard for Latino immigrants in the southwest. Ricardo’s family was one of those who responded by picking up and moving on … and on … and on … and eventually to rural Indiana where they lived in a house owned by our church.
I like to think that my circle of friends would have included Ricardo anyway, but the truth is we probably took him in simply because he was a part of the congregation. And I expect, though I don’t actually remember that our youth pastor made a request of us to welcome him. So, he became a part of my daily life, and getting to know him and the story of his life gave me a perspective on immigration that I wish more people would have.
In the June 15th issue of Christian Century, the editors quote Jeffrey Kaye in their discussion of the current immigration dispute. “Immigration is not a problem to be solved; it is a fact of life. For millennia, humans have been migrating in search of a better life.” In his work on the issue, Kaye often asks people, “If you had to support your family on $3 a day or less, but had the opportunity to cross a border illegally to raise your living standard, would you migrate?” The response, consistently, is “yes” … even from the most vocal anti-immigrant advocates.
People cross borders, legally and illegally, for all different reasons – some good and some bad. And while our faith doesn’t easily translate into public policy suggestions in this area, we do proclaim a Christ who welcomed strangers … who directed his followers to reach out in love to all they met … who went as far as to die in order to offer fuller, deeper life to all. Knowing that and knowing that many, many people get caught in crossfire of American immigration politics simple because their love for their family drove them to leave home and search for something better should at least lead us to listen and respond to the stories of the foreigners we find among us.
And lest we forget, we Anabaptists were strangers in our own lands once upon a time. Our ancestors answered a call to a different way of living, and they were forced to give up houses, family, and all they had known for the sake of their faith. They became immigrants, wandering from country to country and wondering where they would find welcome – or at least acceptance. Now we are all but natives of this country if not this land, and the question for us has become, “How will we treat others who leave behind home and family to come live among us?”
When the time came for Ricardo and his family to move on to Canada, the youth group had a little goodbye party for him. It was nothing big, and I don’t think it would have meant much to me since I wasn’t very close with him except for the fact that at one point Ricardo broke down into tears. “I just want to thank you for everything,” he said…. And, like Ruth, “I hope you will all remember me like I will remember you. You have been so kind to me…. I’ll never forget you.”
There is a lot about love in the scripture we heard today. From Naomi and her daughters we can learn how love binds us together and care for one another. From Ruth we can learn about the power of being steadfast and loyal in love even when it takes us out of our comfort zone. From Boaz, we can learn how we are to love the least of these who are our neighbors without regard for their origins. Each one reaches beyond duty for the sake of love, and that love brings a richness, a fullness to the lives of the others they touch.
Among Jesus’ last words to his disciples were, “by this [the world] will know that you are my disciples, that you love one another.”
It makes you think about how the world sees us….
Ruth 1-2:13
Third in series: "God's People in the Hebrew Scriptures"
Today we continue our series with the Book of Ruth which is strangely appropriate given the current controversy over immigration policy. Though we call the book Ruth, it is as much the story of her mother-in-law, Naomi, as it is hers, and it is full of irony that we miss if we don’t know Hebrew.
Naomi, whose name means sweet, sets out from Bethlehem, the “house of bread,” with her husband because there is a famine in the land. They immigrate to Moab for relief even though Moabites were universally held in contempt by Israelites. There they settle, and their two sons marry Moabite women who Naomi loves as daughters. Eventually, all three men die, leaving Naomi, Orpah, and Ruth widowed and destitute, and Naomi, no longer sweet but embittered, decides to return to her ancestral home because just as bread has finally returned to Bethlehem.
On a deeper level, this story is set in opposition to the book of Judges. As we have heard from the previous two stories in our series, the time of the judges was not Israel at its best. Though the era started out fairly well, the Israelites began to turn away from God, and by the end, as Carrie pointed out, “all the people did what was right in their own eyes.” They lived selfishly and ignored the needs of those around them rather than following the Law that had held them together as a people. Over time that lack of loyalty and kindness led to division and death.
In contrast, Ruth chooses the way of kindness and loyalty. She leaves behind her home, her family, and her country to follow Naomi. She leaves behind a certain amount of security and a future with some hope for a “normal” life. She sets out into an uncertain future in a country where she is sure to be despised for the sake of love, and her faithful love reaches beyond the obligations and requirements of duty to bring a scattered family together in the promise of new life.
Jesus told his disciples, once, that following him might well mean leaving behind mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters, and all the comfort and familiarity of home to make just such a trip into the unknown. Of all the instructions that he gave his followers, that has always seemed the most difficult to understand.
“Sell all you have and give it to the poor.” That’s a hard one, and I haven’t heard of anyone actually doing it – even the disciples. Still, it makes sense.
“If anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn the other also.” Even apart from certain interpretations of this as an act of resistance to the Roman Empire, I can get behind this one. I can even put it into practice from time to time.
But … “I have come to set a man against his father and a daughter against her mother …. And everyone who has left houses or brothers or sisters or father or mother or children for my name’s sake, … will inherit eternal life.” That’s one that gives me pause.
I remember when I was preparing for my baptism about a year after Carrie and I were married. That scripture came around in the lectionary cycle, and it hit me hard. I have no recollection at all of the rest of worship that day. I was stuck, wrestling with the thought that God might require me to leave my family behind. That’s not how I understood God, but it seemed to be a hard fact … right there … staring me in the face.
A few days later, I broached the topic with Carrie and shared my fears that my vows to God might, one day, have to take precedence over my vows to her. To her credit, she responded calmly and compassionately. We talked for awhile, and she reminded me that Jesus’ words were spoken to people who might have to leave their family if they chose to become disciples of Christ not to families who were already committed to that path. She also agreed with my belief that God would not choose to pull families apart … at least most of the time. So, I continued down the path to my dunking with only a manageable amount of anxiety.
Yet, what I shied away from as a possible duty of discipleship (well … ran away kicking and screaming might be a better description), Ruth embraced wholeheartedly. She left behind everything – even her gods – not because she had to, but because of her love. Having known Naomi for 10 years while she was true to her name – that is pleasant and sweet, she stays with her even when the turns of life have twisted her heart, turning her into Mara - bitter and resentful. Perhaps she was motivated by compassion. Perhaps it was something else. Whatever the reason, she models the steadfast love of God and becomes a stranger in a strange land.
Now, the Israelites were not known for treating Moabites - or any other foreigners – very well, especially during the time of the judges. And Naomi didn’t do very much to make the situation any better. She didn’t introduce her to the women of Bethlehem … didn’t explain the situation … didn’t even acknowledge her presence there beside her, turned in on herself as she was. But it seems that things weren’t too bad for Ruth.
She was confident enough in her safety to go out gleaning – to follow along behind the harvesters and pick up any little bits of barley that had fallen to the ground. Gleaning was a sacred right preserved in the Law of Moses as one of the few ways for widows and orphans to sustain themselves, but it was hot and tedious work without any protection from the sun or, apparently, the unwanted attention of the harvesters. So, it was particularly fortunately that Ruth found herself in fields that belonged to Naomi’s cousin, Boaz, who chooses to honor Ruth’s steadfastness with a blessing where others would have ignored and mistreated her as an unwanted immigrant.
When I was in sixteen or seventeen, a boy named Ricardo attended high school with us for a couple of years. He was Guatemalan by birth though he had spent much of his life living in the United States. His parents crossed the border in the 70s trying to escape the harsh realities of civil war. They hoped to find good work and make a better life for Ricardo and his brother and sister, and they were able to do pretty well for awhile.
That was before public sentiment began to turn so strongly against illegal immigrants in the 80s.
When that happened, the hostility of the people around them and increased pressure made life hard for Latino immigrants in the southwest. Ricardo’s family was one of those who responded by picking up and moving on … and on … and on … and eventually to rural Indiana where they lived in a house owned by our church.
I like to think that my circle of friends would have included Ricardo anyway, but the truth is we probably took him in simply because he was a part of the congregation. And I expect, though I don’t actually remember that our youth pastor made a request of us to welcome him. So, he became a part of my daily life, and getting to know him and the story of his life gave me a perspective on immigration that I wish more people would have.
In the June 15th issue of Christian Century, the editors quote Jeffrey Kaye in their discussion of the current immigration dispute. “Immigration is not a problem to be solved; it is a fact of life. For millennia, humans have been migrating in search of a better life.” In his work on the issue, Kaye often asks people, “If you had to support your family on $3 a day or less, but had the opportunity to cross a border illegally to raise your living standard, would you migrate?” The response, consistently, is “yes” … even from the most vocal anti-immigrant advocates.
People cross borders, legally and illegally, for all different reasons – some good and some bad. And while our faith doesn’t easily translate into public policy suggestions in this area, we do proclaim a Christ who welcomed strangers … who directed his followers to reach out in love to all they met … who went as far as to die in order to offer fuller, deeper life to all. Knowing that and knowing that many, many people get caught in crossfire of American immigration politics simple because their love for their family drove them to leave home and search for something better should at least lead us to listen and respond to the stories of the foreigners we find among us.
And lest we forget, we Anabaptists were strangers in our own lands once upon a time. Our ancestors answered a call to a different way of living, and they were forced to give up houses, family, and all they had known for the sake of their faith. They became immigrants, wandering from country to country and wondering where they would find welcome – or at least acceptance. Now we are all but natives of this country if not this land, and the question for us has become, “How will we treat others who leave behind home and family to come live among us?”
When the time came for Ricardo and his family to move on to Canada, the youth group had a little goodbye party for him. It was nothing big, and I don’t think it would have meant much to me since I wasn’t very close with him except for the fact that at one point Ricardo broke down into tears. “I just want to thank you for everything,” he said…. And, like Ruth, “I hope you will all remember me like I will remember you. You have been so kind to me…. I’ll never forget you.”
There is a lot about love in the scripture we heard today. From Naomi and her daughters we can learn how love binds us together and care for one another. From Ruth we can learn about the power of being steadfast and loyal in love even when it takes us out of our comfort zone. From Boaz, we can learn how we are to love the least of these who are our neighbors without regard for their origins. Each one reaches beyond duty for the sake of love, and that love brings a richness, a fullness to the lives of the others they touch.
Among Jesus’ last words to his disciples were, “by this [the world] will know that you are my disciples, that you love one another.”
It makes you think about how the world sees us….
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
